Swiss vote against proposal to cap population at 10 million

Swiss vote against proposal to cap population at 10 million

Swiss vote against proposal to cap population at 10 million

Voters in Switzerland have rejected a proposal to limit the country's population to 10 million.

Results showed nearly 55% of participants voted against and 45% voted for, with a turnout of 60% of the population.

The proposal came from the right-wing Swiss People's Party, which has long campaigned on an anti-immigration platform.

The divisive vote risked putting the country's free movement agreement with the European Union in jeopardy and was opposed by the government, Swiss businesses, and all the other major parties.

Welcoming the no vote, Switzerland's justice minister Beat Jans said it was "a sign of stability, openness and reliability".

Switzerland's population has grown rapidly since 2002, when it stood at 7.3 million. Now it is 9.1 million, 27% of whom are not Swiss citizens.

However, the People Party's argument that capping the population would reduce pressure on transport, housing and the environment seem not to have persuaded enough voters.

Although the Swiss People's Party insisted the population cap was designed to protect Switzerland's public services and its environment, it has a long history of campaigning on an anti-immigrant platform, frequently blaming asylum seekers and minorities for societal problems.

Some voters were seemingly worried at the prospect of losing much-needed workers in tourism, hospitals, and care homes.

Others, in particular Swiss business leaders, feared losing Switzerland's crucial access to Europe's single market.

Over half of all Swiss products are sold into the EU, but their access to Europe's markets depends on Swiss commitment to Europe's free movement of people. Had the population cap been approved, Switzerland would have had to terminate that agreement.

Both the Swiss government and Swiss business leaders say the vote shows non-EU member Switzerland wants to stay close to Europe.

The President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, had stayed out of the campaign, but welcomed the result once the votes were counted, saying: "The Swiss people have spoken. The EU and Switzerland share deep ties and a strong partnership".

But the concerns over high rents, over development, crowded public transport, and rising health costs will not go away because of this particular decision.

Marcel Dettling, the Swiss People's Party's president, said the vote showed that "the population wants solutions. Not a single problem has been solved".

What the Swiss voters have shown though, is that many of them may be weary of the People's Party's continued focus on immigration as the source of Switzerland's problems, while voters themselves are not at all convinced that blaming immigrants, or stricter controls on immigration, are the way to solve them.

Switzerland's system of direct democracy means all major decisions are taken via the ballot box. Campaigners simply have to gather 100,000 signatures to ensure a nationwide vote.

Two young politicians with opposing views on limiting the Swiss population spoke to the BBC prior to the vote.

"We have lost control," complains Nils Fiechter, 29, who represents the Swiss People's Party in canton Bern's parliament.

"Unchecked immigration is leading to Switzerland no longer being Switzerland," he said.

In 2022, Fiechter and his co-president of the People's Party's youth wing were convicted of racial discrimination by the Swiss Federal Court, in relation to a poster they distributed in 2018 targeting Roma and traveller communities.

He believes Switzerland's problems, which he says include a "housing shortage, gridlocked traffic, overburdened schools and strained social services", are a direct result of immigration.

But Helin Genis, a 31-year-old Social Democrat elected to Bern city council, dismissed these arguments as scapegoating.

She told BBC News: "It is not migrants who determine rent levels. It is not migrants who raise health insurance premiums. Nor is it migrants who make political decisions on housing, infrastructure or social investment."

Viewing problems "through the lens of migration does not lead to solutions, but to division", she added.

The results showed a marked difference between urban and rural areas.

Only Swiss citizens were allowed to vote, but in the cities, which have larger immigrant communities than in the countryside, the proposal got a particularly resounding no.

In the capital city Bern, for example, almost 84% of those voting rejected a population cap.

And key tourism areas, where hotels and restaurants depend on foreign labour, were also not impressed with the proposal.

Both canton Graubunden, home to St Moritz, and canton Valais, home to Zermatt and the iconic Matterhorn, said no.

The prospect of the population cap caused alarm at Switzerland's business association, Economiesuisse.

Its chief economist Rudolf Minsch said that if the motion passed, Switzerland "could face challenges in our relations with the European Union".

Brussels has long warned non-EU members that they cannot cherry-pick the advantages of the EU's single market, and wriggle out of commitments like free movement of people.

"The EU is still by far the most important trading partner for Switzerland," explains Minsch, adding that is it is "in our interest to have stable and clear relationships with our main trading partner".

Swiss employers were also worried about labour shortages, and losing access to a Europe-wide pool of skilled workers.

Half of all those who work in Switzerland's hotels are immigrants. Hospitals and care homes are also reliant on foreign workers.

The Swiss People's Party argued that immigration to Switzerland is fuelling an ever-increasing demand for more hospital beds and more places in schools, and that limiting immigration would ease the pressure.

Opponents said this is unrealistic, pointing to 20% of the Swiss population now being over 65.

Young workers, and young taxpayers, are required to staff and fund the needs of an ageing population – and Switzerland is not creating those young workers itself, they warned.

Switzerland, like its neighbours in Europe, is spending more on defence, and despite its neutrality, is planning closer defence ties with its neighbours.

Jon Pult, a member of parliament for the Social Democrats, told the BBC that his biggest fear about any population cap was being alone in an "unstable and dangerous world".

Reuters Signs stand in front of a building, on the day of the vote on a plan backed by the right-wing Swiss People
Two posters side by side - one on the left is a Yes-vote poster calling for "No to 10 million Swiss, and one on the right backs the No-vote, condemning the plan as a "chaos initiative"
#against #cap #proposal #swiss #vote


Upprunaleg slóð:
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c20ygjem17zo?at_medium=RSS&at_campaign=rss

📰 Aðrar fréttir

Elizabeth Smart birtir tilfinningaþrungna færslu eftir tap í vaxtarrækt
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Elizabeth Smart birtir tilfinningaþrungna færslu eftir tap í vaxtarrækt
Elizabeth Smart birti tilfinningaþrungna færslu á samfélagsmiðlum eftir að hafa hafnað í neðsta sæti í vaxtarræktarkeppni. Hún sagðist hafa skemmt sér...
Þurfum að kveikja inni í krökkunum vaxtarhugarfar
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Þurfum að kveikja inni í krökkunum vaxtarhugarfar
„Ég persónulega trúi því að samræmd próf séu eitt það besta jöfnunartæki sem að til er. Af því að þar ertu með raunverulega, sameiginlega mælieiningu ...
„Ætlunin er ekki að að­laga þá aftur að sam­fé­laginu“ - Vísir
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
„Ætlunin er ekki að að­laga þá aftur að sam­fé­laginu“ - Vísir
„Í vikunni sem leið var þekktum sakamanni vísað úr landi með 30 ára endurkomubann til Íslands og raunar til allra 29 Schengen ríkjanna,“ skrifar Þorbj...
Vilja öll greiða at­kvæði um að kljúfa sig frá Bret­landi - Vísir
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Vilja öll greiða at­kvæði um að kljúfa sig frá Bret­landi - Vísir
Telegraph greinir frá þessu en miðillinn segir leiðtoga landanna þriggja ætla að hittast á sögulegum fundi í Cardiff á morgun, mánudag. Nú séu í fyrst...
Krist­rún ræðir málin í Sprengi­sandi - Vísir
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Krist­rún ræðir málin í Sprengi­sandi - Vísir
Sömuleiðis verður Ásgeir Jónsson, Seðlabankastjóri, í viðtali. Það er ekkert annað land í okkar heimshluta með verðtryggingarkerfi eins og það er á Ís...
Hvað eru varnarefni í matvælum?
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Hvað eru varnarefni í matvælum?
Heildsalan Bananar inkallaði nýlega Pinkids epli vegna ólöglegs varnarefnis. Þetta er ekki í fyrsta sinn sem matvara er innkölluð vegna varnarefna.Þó ...
Kaldi og rigning
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Kaldi og rigning
Lægð nálgast landið úr suðvestri og beinir mildara lofti til landsins, en í nótt frysti víða norðaustantil á landinu.Þá er austan og suðaustan kalda o...
Reform's £72m donations 'entirely in line with law', Jenrick says
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Reform's £72m donations 'entirely in line with law', Jenrick says
The government is trying to change the law on donations to UK political parties from British expats.
Bandaríkin verji sína hagsmuni, ekki íslenska
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Bandaríkin verji sína hagsmuni, ekki íslenska
Rasmus Gjedssø Bertelsen er danskur prófessor í norðurslóðafræðum við Norðurslóðaháskólann í Tromsö í Noregi. Þar rannsakar hann og fylgist grannt með...
Kolbrún Bergþórsdóttir skrifar: Andúð og ofstæki
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Kolbrún Bergþórsdóttir skrifar: Andúð og ofstæki
Mynd Þorgerður Katrín Gunnarsdóttir, utanríkisráðherra
Tromp á hendi Trumps?
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Tromp á hendi Trumps?
Tromp á hendi Trumps? Danski her­inn hef­ur ár­um sam­an mátt búa við nið­ur­skurð, sem bæði hef­ur bitn­að á tækj­um og mann­skap. Slæm­ur að­bún­að­...
Haustlitadýrð við Þingvallavatn
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Haustlitadýrð við Þingvallavatn
Náttúran skartaði sínu fegursta nærri Vinaskógi við Þingvallavatn í gær þegar myndatökumaður Ríkissjónvarpsins Arnór Fannar Rúnarsson var þar á ferð.H...
Nætur­frost norðaustantil - Vísir
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Nætur­frost norðaustantil - Vísir
Þar segir að búist sé við austan og suðaustan kalda og rigningu í dag. Þá verði strekkingur með suðurströndinni. Hægari vindur verði á Norður- og Aust...
Sam­kvæminu slúttað vegna brots á lögum - Vísir
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Sam­kvæminu slúttað vegna brots á lögum - Vísir
Þetta kemur fram í dagbók lögreglunnar á höfuðborgarsvæðinu. Þar koma engar frekari upplýsingar fram um málið, nema að það hafi átt sér stað í umdæmi ...
Kærasti grunaður um manndrápstilraun
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Kærasti grunaður um manndrápstilraun
Kærasti grunaður um manndrápstilraun Landspítalinn í Fossvogi Mynd: Víkingur Maður var í sumar úrskurðaður í gæsluvarðhald vegna gruns um tilraun til ...
Fundu blóðuga exi og kaðal eftir að kærastinn var hand­tekinn - Vísir
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Fundu blóðuga exi og kaðal eftir að kærastinn var hand­tekinn - Vísir
Þetta kemur fram í gæsluvarðhaldsúrskurði á hendur manninum sem var kveðinn upp í lok júlímánaðar, en birtist á vef dómstólanna fyrir skömmu. Málið er...
Fjöldi Jemena á flótta undan stríðsátökum
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 2
Fjöldi Jemena á flótta undan stríðsátökum
Um 1.400 flúðu frá Jemen til Djibútí á einum sólarhring vegna átaka milli stjórnarhersins í Jemen og uppreisnarsveita Húta. Efnahagsráðuneyti Djibútí ...
Jemenar á flótta undan stríðsátökum
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
Jemenar á flótta undan stríðsátökum
Um 1.400 flúðu frá Jemen til Djibútí á einum sólarhring vegna átaka milli stjórnarhersins í Jemen og uppreisnarsveita Húta. Efnahagsráðuneyti Djibútí ...
Audi chooses Gran Canaria for major international event and vehicle testing
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 2
Audi chooses Gran Canaria for major international event and vehicle testing
Gran Canaria has become an international showcase for one of the world's biggest car manufacturers, with Audi using the island for a major global conv...
Heat warnings activated across the Canary Islands today as temperatures climb and calima returns
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 2
Heat warnings activated across the Canary Islands today as temperatures climb and calima returns
The Canary Islands are facing another hot and dusty day today, Sunday 13th September, as temperatures rise again and official health warnings for extr...
Krakkatía vikunnar: Tollering, Sims og Einar Ás­kell - Vísir
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 2
Krakkatía vikunnar: Tollering, Sims og Einar Ás­kell - Vísir
Láttu á reyna hér fyrir neðan og sjáðu hversu mörg stig þú hefur upp úr krafsinu. Það er vissulega mikið í húfi en að sjálfsögðu er bannað að svindla....
Scuba diver dies after getting into difficulty off Tenerife coast
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 2
Scuba diver dies after getting into difficulty off Tenerife coast
A scuba diver has died after getting into difficulties in the sea off Radazul, in the Tenerife municipality of El Rosario, prompting a major response ...
15 ára dreng bjargað í Bergingshafi
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 2
15 ára dreng bjargað í Bergingshafi
15 ára dreng var bjargað í Beringshafi úti fyrir ströndum St. Lawrence-eyju í síðustu viku eftir að hafa verið á reki á kili smábáts í tvo sólarhringa...
15 ára dreng bjargað í Beringshafi
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 1
15 ára dreng bjargað í Beringshafi
15 ára dreng var bjargað í Beringshafi úti fyrir ströndum St. Lawrence-eyju í síðustu viku eftir að hafa verið á reki á kili smábáts í tvo sólarhringa...
PM's top security adviser says Europe faces hard winter to keep pressure on Putin
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 2
PM's top security adviser says Europe faces hard winter to keep pressure on Putin
In rare public remarks, Jonathan Powell said now was not the time for European nations to take their "foot off the gas".
One dead, 102 rescued from Indonesian ferry that went missing in Java Sea
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 2
One dead, 102 rescued from Indonesian ferry that went missing in Java Sea
The nation's search and rescue team said it lost contact with the Virgo Transport 8 in the early hours of Sunday morning.
„Óþekkt kona“ hlaut Gullna ljónið
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 2
„Óþekkt kona“ hlaut Gullna ljónið
Danska kvikmyndin Óþekkt kona (d. Kvinde ukendt) hlaut Gullna ljónið, aðalverðlaun kvikmyndahátíðarinnar í Feneyjum, sem veitt voru í gær. Aðalleikkon...
'She's back': Fans dance, sing and cry after Céline Dion's comeback concert in Paris
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 3
'She's back': Fans dance, sing and cry after Céline Dion's comeback concert in Paris
Thousands turned out to witness Céline Dion perform in Paris on Saturday, her first show after a six year illness-induced hiatus.
Lengsta borðhald í heimi í Búkarest
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 3
Lengsta borðhald í heimi í Búkarest
Yfir 20.000 gestir mættu á óvenjulegt borðhald í Búkarest í Rúmeníu í gær. Gestirnir sátu við borð sem var 5,055 metra langt og náði frá Unirii-breiðg...
AI staff 'genuinely frightened' for humanity's future, ex-Anthropic researcher tells BBC
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 3
AI staff 'genuinely frightened' for humanity's future, ex-Anthropic researcher tells BBC
Jacob Coxon tells the BBC that there's a strong chance AI could end humanity if the rate of development is not reined in.
Critics celebrate Céline Dion's 'risky' comeback show in Paris
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 3
Critics celebrate Céline Dion's 'risky' comeback show in Paris
The iconic Canadian singer kicked off her long-awaited comeback show in Paris on Saturday, after a six-year hiatus due to health issues.
They lost their jobs after posting about Charlie Kirk, but some have no regrets
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 4
They lost their jobs after posting about Charlie Kirk, but some have no regrets
Some people fired in the wake of Kirk's assassination have won big settlements from employers, others have had to start over from scratch.
Celine Dion með langþráða endurkomu
📅 13.09.2026 👁️ 4
Celine Dion með langþráða endurkomu
Kanadíska söngdívan Celine Dion hélt sína fyrstu tónleika í sex ár í Plenitude Arena í Nanterre, úthverfi Parísar í Frakklandi í kvöld.Hún hóf tónleik...
For­stjórar gervi­greindar­fyrir­tækja segja hættu á ferðum og hægja þurfi á þróun - Vísir
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 4
For­stjórar gervi­greindar­fyrir­tækja segja hættu á ferðum og hægja þurfi á þróun - Vísir
Dario Amodei, forstjóri og meðstofnandi Anthropic, segir að þróunin sé í dag það hröð að ekki sé hægt að tryggja öryggi á sama tíma. Þetta kemur fram ...
Drag Race co-creator Fenton Bailey speaks out after BBC axe
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 3
Drag Race co-creator Fenton Bailey speaks out after BBC axe
The BBC is cutting the show because of financial pressures, sparking discussion about LGBTQ+ representation on TV.
Some dentists say more young people are grinding their teeth - are you one of them?
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 4
Some dentists say more young people are grinding their teeth - are you one of them?
Millions of us do it, though few of us realise we do - but getting the right treatment can be life-changing.
Tom Felton: I'm so excited to see Rupert Grint play Ron Weasley again
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 1
Tom Felton: I'm so excited to see Rupert Grint play Ron Weasley again
The Harry Potter actor talks about taking on Broadway and his friendship with former co-stars
Árásir á almenna borgara í Úkraínu
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 4
Árásir á almenna borgara í Úkraínu
Að minnsta kosti níu voru drepnir og sextíu eru særðir eftir árásir Rússa í Úkraínu í dag. Þar af særðust 37 í árás á fjölbýlishús í Odessu og tveggja...
Student loan terms to be made clearer in England
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 4
Student loan terms to be made clearer in England
Changes will spell out that governments can change rules and that career choices affect repayments.
Will the Thirlwall report change the debate about Lucy Letby?
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 3
Will the Thirlwall report change the debate about Lucy Letby?
The inquiry into the former nurse is expected to find failures by her hospital to ensure patient safety.
Diljit Dosanjh: Punjabi singer makes history under the famous Wembley arch
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 3
Diljit Dosanjh: Punjabi singer makes history under the famous Wembley arch
Wembley Stadium billed Diljit Dosanjh as the first Punjabi singer to headline the iconic music venue.
Óttast að fjár­magn til náms­gagna rati ekki rétta leið - Vísir
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 3
Óttast að fjár­magn til náms­gagna rati ekki rétta leið - Vísir
Samkvæmt því sem hefur komið fram á meirihluti fjármagnsins að fara í ný námsgögn á grunnskólastigi með áherslu á STEAM-greinar en einnig hefur verið ...
US Open 2026 results: Elena Rybakina beats Aryna Sabalenka to win New York title
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 4
US Open 2026 results: Elena Rybakina beats Aryna Sabalenka to win New York title
Elena Rybakina demonstrates why she is the best women's player in the world by beating Aryna Sabalenka to win her first US Open title.
Framhjáhaldið spennandi þar til mágkonan varpaði fram sprengju
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 3
Framhjáhaldið spennandi þar til mágkonan varpaði fram sprengju
„Það var spennandi að halda framhjá með systur eiginkonu minnar, þar til hún varð ólétt.“Svona hefst bréf 37 ára karlmanns til kynlífs- og sambandsráð...
Meena and Minal: Best friends for decades - until a DNA test revealed they were sisters
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 4
Meena and Minal: Best friends for decades - until a DNA test revealed they were sisters
Meena Geltink and Minal Tijssen were adopted from orphanages in Mumbai in the 1980s and grew up in the Netherlands.
Lofar bót eftir að varað var við honum: „Rangt af mér og á því biðst ég af­sökunar“ - Vísir
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 2
Lofar bót eftir að varað var við honum: „Rangt af mér og á því biðst ég af­sökunar“ - Vísir
Hann hafnar því ekki að hafa beitt sömu aðferð í öðrum háskólum en kveðst ekki ætla að afla sér upplýsinga með þessum hætti aftur. Búið sé að eyða umr...
Mikil aukning í sjúkraflugi – lífsspursmál að halda flugvöllum um landið í lagi
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 4
Mikil aukning í sjúkraflugi – lífsspursmál að halda flugvöllum um landið í lagi
Sjúkraflug jókst um ríflega 40% í júlí samanborið við í fyrra. Ef fram fer sem horfir verður flogið yfir þúsund sinnum á árinu í sjúkraflugi. Sérhæfin...
Trump: US president's comments on a united Ireland may have targeted an audience across the Atlantic
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 4
Trump: US president's comments on a united Ireland may have targeted an audience across the Atlantic
Nobody could have predicted that today's main global headline would be Trump's desire to see a unified Ireland.
Sólveig Anna svarar hörðu viðbrögðunum fullum hálsi - „Ég hefði enn ekkert fengið greitt fyrir ósiðlega hegðun mína“
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 2
Sólveig Anna svarar hörðu viðbrögðunum fullum hálsi - „Ég hefði enn ekkert fengið greitt fyrir ósiðlega hegðun mína“
Sólveig Anna Jónsdóttir formaður Eflingar sér ekkert eftir orðum sínum um þingmanninn Dag B. Eggertsson og bróður hans Gauta B. Eggertssyni hagfræðipr...
Minntust Hönnuh Jane í Áskirkju
📅 12.09.2026 👁️ 4
Minntust Hönnuh Jane í Áskirkju
Minningarstund var haldin til minningar um Hönnuh Jane Large í Áskirkju í Reykjavík í dag. Hún var ein þriggja ungmenna sem létust í bílslysi á Krýsuv...