Musk v Altman - 5 big moments in the tech bros' OpenAI trial

Musk v Altman - 5 big moments in the tech bros' OpenAI trial

Musk v Altman - 5 big moments in the tech bros' OpenAI trial

It is the legal showdown that has pitted two of the biggest names in tech, Elon Musk and Sam Altman, against each other.

At stake is the future of one of the world's most valuable start-ups, ChatGPT-maker OpenAI, along with the reputations of Altman - the company's boss - and Musk, the man he founded it with.

The central claim the jury has now retired to consider is Musk's argument his former friend "stole a charity", cheating him out of a fortune (albeit a tiny one, by Musk's standards) along the way - something Altman strongly rejects.

But there's been much more to the trial than that.

Over the past three weeks, myself and other reporters have been glued to our seats at the federal court in California as the evidence ranged from explosive text messages to revelations of free Teslas allegedly offered in exchange for power.

It has all been presided over by a no-nonsense judge who will take the jury's decision under advisement, but ultimately decides which side prevails.

For those who have been unable to follow every twist and turn, here are five big things we learned from the court battle.

Elon Musk's central claim in this lawsuit is that Altman lied to him about his commitment to OpenAI's non-profit status.

But this trial has ended up being more than one very famous man's word against another's.

A parade of witnesses - many of them also very high-profile figures in the world of tech - took to the stand during the trial and said they had never heard of or seen evidence of any such commitment from Musk himself.

Witnesses included OpenAI co-founder Ilya Sutskever, former OpenAI board member, Tasha McCauley, and even Microsoft boss Satya Nadella - who insisted his company did extensive due diligence before investing billions into OpenAI.

Of course, Nadella has skin in the game. Microsoft is a co-defendant, accused by Musk of aiding and abetting in Altman's alleged scheme.

Nevertheless, it was striking that this trial has not just been about Musk against Altman - there has been a barrage of voices contradicting the claims of the world's richest man.

Being able to call on some high-powered support from the witness stand hasn't stopped the questions about Altman's trusthworthiness.

In the weeks leading up to the trial, Altman had been the subject of a blistering New Yorker magazine profile by investigative reporter Ronan Farrow.

Zoning in on his career and moments such as his dramatic ousting from OpenAI in 2023, the story portrayed Altman as a pathological liar.

Musk's lawyer Steven Molo made the most of this.

"Are you completely trustworthy?" he asked Altman in his first question of cross examination.

Altman responded with: "I believe so." Molo ran with it.

"You don't know whether you're completely trustworthy?" he queried.

While the OpenAI boss asked to amend his answer to "yes", his character remained under a harsh spotlight throughout the trial.

Jurors heard from former OpenAI board members and executives - some in person, others via videotaped sworn depositions - detailing first-hand experiences of Altman allegedly failing to be forthright.

They also learned of his extensive investments in private start-ups, some of which have brokered deals with OpenAI.

A power purchasing agreement with nuclear energy start-up Helion Energy was flagged as particularly worrisome, given the firm has yet to ever deliver any power.

Altman was, until recently, chairman of Helion's board and holds a stake worth more than $1.5bn.

Musk v Altman wasn't just about the tech bros.

Other colourful characters who got their star turn turning this trial included Judge Gonzalez Rogers, who oversaw it.

She kept jurors, lawyers and media on a strict schedule, with only two twenty-minute breaks per day and no lunch time to ensure maximum alertness.

This judge had complete command of her courtroom and had no qualms about lambasting anyone who ran afoul of the rules.

That applied to observers who deigned to take photographs of the case's famous players in the courthouse and lawyers who pushed their questions into territory the judge had previously made clear were off-limits.

But she wasn't all business.

When the court experienced audio issues early in the trial, she addressed it and then deadpanned: "What can I tell you? We are funded by the federal government."

The drama of the trial, which could not be streamed in video, was also brought to life throughout by sketch artist Vicki Behringer, who painstakingly captured it in water-coloured splendour each day.

Once upon a time, Musk was Altman's hero.

The deterioration of that relationship was not the only highly personal situation the court focussed on.

Musk was generally confident, even combative, in his appearance as the first witness to take the stand.

But he got noticeably flustered when asked about his relationship with Shivon Zilis.

"We live together and she's the mother of four of my children," he acknowledged.

He described Zilis, an executive at his firm Neuralink, as one of his senior advisors.

She told the court that while also member of the OpenAI board, the billionaire had offered her his sperm after noticing she had no children - not your everyday boardroom interaction.

The fact Musk was to be the father to her children was something she, later, did not reveal to OpenAI colleagues until a media report was imminent.

An intriguing witness, she was almost robotic-sounding in her answers on the stand.

Her demeanour seemed warmer over text, where her job as 'Elon whisperer' came across most clearly.

She left the board after Musk started xAI.

"When the father of your babies starts a competitive effort and will recruit out of OpenAI, there is nothing to be done," Zilis wrote to a friend.

For outsiders, Musk v Altman offered a crash course in how power is wielded in Silicon Valley.

Want to lowball your co-founders? Give them free Teslas! (That was Elon, allegedly.)

Looking to ensure loyalty? Pay your most important strategic partner on the side. (That was Sam, allegedly.)

Musk's attorneys tried to diminish Altman before the jury, painting him as someone who tried to use a connection to Musk to bolster his own status.

In turn, Altman claimed Musk suggested control of OpenAI should go to his children.

Text messages divulged during the trial also put power struggles behind closed doors on full display.

These ranged from revealing Altman's frenzied response to his abrupt sacking in 2023, asking a former colleague at one point - "still don't want me?"

That same colleague in turn described how Altman was being replaced by Twitch boss Emmett Shear, or as she called him in her message "rando Twitch guy".

The flippant-sounding messages - as well as seeing these larger-than-life personalities sipping lattes around the courthouse - could make them seem a little less important.

Yet they still control technology that impacts the lives of billions of people. And they are embroiled in a row worth billions of dollars.

It is now over to the jury - and ultimately Judge Gonzalez Rogers - to decide what happens next.

Sign up for our Tech Decoded newsletter to follow the world's top tech stories and trends. Outside the UK? Sign up here.

AFP via Getty Images A composite image of Elon Musk on the left and Sam Altman on the right.
Reuters A court sketch of Sam Altman watching a screen showing himself on a podcast.
Getty Images Shivon Zilis holding hands with Elon Musk. Zilis is wearing a pale dress and jacket, and Musk is wearing a suit and a red scarf. Both are smiling.
Getty Images A model of Elon Musk wearing three hats which say "dork", "Maga", "douche". The model is holding a bag labelled "ketamine" and is in a mock Tesla car where the licence plate says "BNKRUPT". In the foreground is a protestor with a sign which says "wake up".
A green promotional banner with black squares and rectangles forming pixels, moving in from the right. The text says: “Tech Decoded: The world’s biggest tech news in your inbox every Monday.”
#altman #big #moments #musk #the


Upprunaleg slóð:
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cg7pj8p5mv4o?at_medium=RSS&at_campaign=rss

📰 Aðrar fréttir

Davíð Þór Björgvinsson skrifar: ESB og hinar dreifðu byggðir Íslands
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Davíð Þór Björgvinsson skrifar: ESB og hinar dreifðu byggðir Íslands
Umræðan um ESB beinist mikið að sjávarútvegi og landbúnaði, enda skipta þessar atvinnugreinar miklu máli fyrir efnahagslíf landsins og hinar dreifðu b...
Conduct of two officers in Henry Nowak case investigated
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Conduct of two officers in Henry Nowak case investigated
Henry Nowak, 18, was handcuffed as he lay dying after being stabbed by Vickrum Digwa in December 2025.
First new double-decker buses come into service in Tenerife today
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
First new double-decker buses come into service in Tenerife today
Tenerife's public transport network has entered a new chapter with the introduction today (1st July) of the island's first-ever double-decker buses, a...
Village People frontman Victor Willis dies aged 74
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Village People frontman Victor Willis dies aged 74
Victor Willis was the band's frontman and co-wrote most of their hit songs including YMCA.
Dæmd fyrir misnotkun á debetkorti vistmanns hjúkrunarheimilis
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Dæmd fyrir misnotkun á debetkorti vistmanns hjúkrunarheimilis
Héraðsdómur Vestfjarða dæmdi nýverið konu á þrítugsaldri í þriggja mánaða skilorðsbundið fangelsi og til greiðslu tæpra 1,2 milljóna króna auk vaxta f...
Komst á bragð skemmdarverka í bar­áttunni við Kristján Lofts­son - Vísir
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Komst á bragð skemmdarverka í bar­áttunni við Kristján Lofts­son - Vísir
Coronado fæddist í Kaliforníu árið 1966 og er af ættbálki Yoeme-frumbyggja. Hann hneigðist ungur til herskárrar baráttu fyrir dýra- og umhverfisvernd....
Hælisleitendur verði rukkaðir um húsnæði og uppihald
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Hælisleitendur verði rukkaðir um húsnæði og uppihald
Hælisleitendur í Bretlandi verða krafðir um að endurgreiðslu fyrir húsnæði og fjárhagsstuðning sem þeir fá ef frumvarp bresku ríkisstjórnarinnar verðu...
Kona féll fram af svölum hjá Eir hjúkrunarheimili og lést
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Kona féll fram af svölum hjá Eir hjúkrunarheimili og lést
Rannsókn stendur yfir á láti konu sem féll fram af svölum á hjúkrunarheimili Eir í Grafarvogi á sunnudag. Vísir greindi frá. Forstjóri Eir, Eybjörg Ha...
Séra Þórir Stephensen er látinn
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Séra Þórir Stephensen er látinn
Séra Þórir Stephensen, fyrrverandi dómkirkjuprestur, er látinn. Hann lést á hjúkrunarheimilinu Skjóli í gær, á 95. aldursári. Frá þessu er greint í Mo...
Mokgræðir á rafmyntum - Vísir
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Mokgræðir á rafmyntum - Vísir
Þetta sýna opinber skjöl sem birt voru í gær, að því er NBC greinir frá. Alls er upphæðin um 1,4 milljarðar dala, sem jafngildir um 176 milljörðum ísl...
Öldruð kona lést eftir fall af svölum á hjúkrunarheimili í Grafarvogi
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Öldruð kona lést eftir fall af svölum á hjúkrunarheimili í Grafarvogi
Öldruð kona lést eftir að hafa fallið fram af svölum á hjúkrunarheimilinu Eir í Grafarvogi síðastliðinn sunnudag. Vísir greindi fyrstur frá málinu nú ...
Highest official temperature recorded in Gran Canaria as heatwave grips the islands
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Highest official temperature recorded in Gran Canaria as heatwave grips the islands
Tejeda, in the mountains of Gran Canaria, recorded the highest temperature in the Canary Islands yesterday (Tuesday) as the ongoing heatwave pushed of...
Lést eftir fall af svölum hjúkrunarheimilis
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Lést eftir fall af svölum hjúkrunarheimilis
Öldruð kona lést eftir að hafa fallið fram af svölum á hjúkrunarheimilinu Eir í Grafarvogi á sunnudag. Miðlæg rannsóknardeild lögreglunnar rannsakar a...
Úkraínu­menn kaupa sex­tán Gripen E frá Sví­þjóð - Vísir
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Úkraínu­menn kaupa sex­tán Gripen E frá Sví­þjóð - Vísir
Vólódimír Selenskí Úkraínuforseti greindi frá samkomulaginu á Telegram, þar sem hann sagði að fyrstu þoturnar yrðu afhentar á næsta ári. Þess ber að g...
New €3 customs charge comes into force today for Temu, Shein and AliExpress orders
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
New €3 customs charge comes into force today for Temu, Shein and AliExpress orders
People shopping online in the Canary Islands will now face the new customs charge on many low-value purchases from outside the European Union, as a ne...
Bandaríkjaforseti hagnaðist um rúman milljarð dollara á síðasta ári
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Bandaríkjaforseti hagnaðist um rúman milljarð dollara á síðasta ári
Donald Trump Bandaríkjaforseti hagnaðist um rúman einn milljarð dollara á rafmyntaviðskiptum á síðasta ári samkvæmt fjárhagsuppgjöri sem birt var í gæ...
Bandaríkjaforseti hagnaðist um rúman milljarð dollara í fyrra
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Bandaríkjaforseti hagnaðist um rúman milljarð dollara í fyrra
Donald Trump Bandaríkjaforseti hagnaðist um rúman einn milljarð dollara á rafmyntaviðskiptum á síðasta ári samkvæmt fjárhagsuppgjöri sem birt var í gæ...
Suðlæg átt og rigning
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Suðlæg átt og rigning
Skil frá hægfara lægð mjakast yfir landið og henni fylgja suðlægar áttir og rigning með köflum. Hiti að 17 stigum í dag en aðeins 13 á morgun, að því ...
Thomas Möller skrifar: Glöggt er gests augað
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Thomas Möller skrifar: Glöggt er gests augað
Mynd Í sumar hef ég farið í tvær hringferðir um landið sem ökuleiðsö
„Áttu aukaherbergi?“ – Bresk stjórnvöld vilja fá almenning til að hýsa flóttamenn
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
„Áttu aukaherbergi?“ – Bresk stjórnvöld vilja fá almenning til að hýsa flóttamenn
Breski innanríkisráðherrann Shabana Mahmood hyggst kynna nýtt fyrirkomulag þar sem meira en tíu þúsund flóttamenn myndu koma til Bretlands fyrir árið ...
Grætti nánast alla í at­höfninni - Vísir
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Grætti nánast alla í at­höfninni - Vísir
Unnur Elísabet Gunnarsdóttir ber marga hatta og hefur komið víða við í íslensku listasenunni. Hún er leikstjóri, leikkona, dansari, fjöllistakona og n...
Séra Þórir Stephen­sen er látinn - Vísir
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Séra Þórir Stephen­sen er látinn - Vísir
Morgunblaðið greinir frá andláti hans. Þórir fæddist í Reykjavík þann 1. ágúst 1931 og hefði þannig orðið 95 ára eftir mánuð. Hann var vígður til pres...
Féll fram af svölum á hjúkrunaheimili og lést - Vísir
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Féll fram af svölum á hjúkrunaheimili og lést - Vísir
Grétar Stefánsson, aðalvarðstjóri á lögreglustöð fjögur sem sinnir meðal annars verkefnum í Grafarvogi, segir útkallið hafa borist sunnudaginn 28. jún...
Lög­regla rann­sakar tvö inn­brot í mið­borginni - Vísir
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Lög­regla rann­sakar tvö inn­brot í mið­borginni - Vísir
Tveir gistu fangageymslur í morgun og 48 mál voru bókuð á vaktinni. Einn var kærður fyrir vörslu fíkniefna og brot á vopnalögum og þá voru tveir ökume...
Færri með fjárhagsaðstoð en fleiri hjá barnavernd
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Færri með fjárhagsaðstoð en fleiri hjá barnavernd
Færri með fjárhagsaðstoð en fleiri hjá barnavernd Ný árs­skýrsla vel­ferð­ar­sviðs Reykja­vík­ur­borg­ar sýn­ir að færri nutu fjár­hags­að­stoð­ar í f...
Drukknanir vegna slysa á skemmtibátum ekki fleiri í tíu ár
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Drukknanir vegna slysa á skemmtibátum ekki fleiri í tíu ár
Alls hafa 17 Norðmenn drukknað í tengslum við siglingar á skemmtibátum á fyrsta helmingi þessa árs, samkvæmt norsku siglingamálastofnunni.Norska ríkis...
Chris Mason: The crunching trade offs and big numbers Burnham may soon confront
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Chris Mason: The crunching trade offs and big numbers Burnham may soon confront
The BBC's political editor Chris Mason reflects on the fallout from the Defence Investment Plan.
Superdry co-founder was my boss when he raped me
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Superdry co-founder was my boss when he raped me
The woman raped by James Holder exclusively reveals she worked for him and had to face him days after he attacked her.
Woman raped by Superdry co-founder was working for him at the time
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Woman raped by Superdry co-founder was working for him at the time
She described feeling fear and dread as she returned to her job, working for James Holder, after the attack.
Teen rape victim speaks of 'lasting pain' as Fordingbridge review begins
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Teen rape victim speaks of 'lasting pain' as Fordingbridge review begins
The teenager is one of two girls who were raped by two boys in Fordingbridge, Hampshire.
Watch: Mount Etna eruption creates trail of bright orange lava
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 0
Watch: Mount Etna eruption creates trail of bright orange lava
A stream of thick orange lava was seen trailing from Europe's biggest active volcano, Mount Etna in Italy, snaking through the mountain.
Katarar reyna að miðla málum í Doha
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Katarar reyna að miðla málum í Doha
Sérlegur erindreki Bandaríkjanna Steve Witkoff og Jared Kushner, tengdasonur Donalds Trumps Bandaríkjaforseta, eru komnir til Katar til fundar við mil...
Eldur kviknaði í bíl í bílakjallara
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Eldur kviknaði í bíl í bílakjallara
Eldur kviknaði í bíl í bílakjallara í Bryggjuhverfi í Grafarvogi í nótt. Slökkvilið höfuðborgarsvæðisins fékk útkall skömmu eftir klukkan eitt og var ...
World Cup 2026: Thomas Tuchel says England will stick to Southgate penalty plan
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
World Cup 2026: Thomas Tuchel says England will stick to Southgate penalty plan
England manager Thomas Tuchel had revealed that his team will follow his predecessor Sir Gareth Southgate's penalty shootout blueprint at the World Cu...
Lögregla lýsir eftir Cezary
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Lögregla lýsir eftir Cezary
Lögreglan á Vesturlandi lýsir eftir Cezary Kobiela, 15 ára dreng sem fór frá Borgarnesi í gær með strætó suður til Reykjavíkur eða Akraness. Í tilkynn...
Trump made more than $1bn from crypto in first year back in office
📅 01.07.2026 👁️ 1
Trump made more than $1bn from crypto in first year back in office
The president earned millions more from real estate, Trump-themed Bibles, watches and other items.
Dæmdur í fangelsi fyrir að hrella fyrr­verandi kærustu - Vísir
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
Dæmdur í fangelsi fyrir að hrella fyrr­verandi kærustu - Vísir
Asad Hussain, búsettur nærri Manchester í Bretlandi, hefur verið dæmdur í átta ára fangelsi fyrir að sitja um konu sem olli henni alvarlegum ótta, lík...
Þúsundir tonna af íslenskum perlusandi flutt út árlega
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
Þúsundir tonna af íslenskum perlusandi flutt út árlega
Síðustu tuttugu ár hefur sandnáman við Stokksnes verið gjöful. Á hverju ári eru hátt í fjörutíu þúsund tonn af möl tekin úr um átta kílómetra langri f...
Ekki Trump-mál heldur réttlætismál
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
Ekki Trump-mál heldur réttlætismál
Ekki Trump-mál heldur réttlætismál Fréttin30. júní 2026Geir Ágústsson, Íþróttir, TransmálLeave a Comment Geir Ágústsson skrifar: Hæstiréttur Bandaríkj...
Sex mánaða gamalt barn lést í úkraínskri drónaárás á Moskvuhérað
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
Sex mánaða gamalt barn lést í úkraínskri drónaárás á Moskvuhérað
Sex mánaða gamalt barn lést í úkraínskri drónaárás á Moskvuhérað Fréttin30. júní 2026Erlent, ÚkraínustríðiðLeave a Comment Sex mánaða gamalt barn lést...
Why Gen Z are planning for life without a state pension
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
Why Gen Z are planning for life without a state pension
Many younger people do not believe the state pension will exist when they are older
E-scooters being advertised for commuting despite UK road ban
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
E-scooters being advertised for commuting despite UK road ban
A Press Association investigation found major retailers advertising e-scooters for "commuting" and "urban riding".
Women with PMOS should have yearly NHS checks, says health watchdog
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
Women with PMOS should have yearly NHS checks, says health watchdog
Despite affecting millions of women in the UK, PMOS is still under-diagnosed and inconsistently managed, say experts.
UK charities launch Venezuela earthquakes appeal
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
UK charities launch Venezuela earthquakes appeal
At least 1,700 people have died and tens of thousands are feared missing after the twin quakes.
Plea for households to read energy meter as prices rise
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
Plea for households to read energy meter as prices rise
Household energy prices have risen by 13% a year as regulator Ofgem's latest price cap kicks in.
Leyniþjónustan rannsakar grínhljómsveit sem „tók Trump af lífi“ – Hafa tekið forseta af lífi í áratugi
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
Leyniþjónustan rannsakar grínhljómsveit sem „tók Trump af lífi“ – Hafa tekið forseta af lífi í áratugi
Bandaríska leyniþjónustan hefur haft þungarokkshljómsveitina GWAR til rannsóknar vegna „aftöku“ á Donald Trump á tónleikum. GWAR, sem er grínsveit og ...
Lögreglan leitar að 15 ára dreng
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
Lögreglan leitar að 15 ára dreng
Lögreglan á Vesturlandi hefur lýst eftir Cezary Kobiela, 15 ára dreng. Cezary fór frá Borgarnesi í gær með strætó suður til Reykjavíkur eða Akraness.C...
Sér Blöndu­ós eflast með byggðalínu og virkjunum - Vísir
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
Sér Blöndu­ós eflast með byggðalínu og virkjunum - Vísir
Við Blönduós er verið að tvöfalda gagnaver Borealis og kalla framkvæmdirnar á allt að tvöhundruð manns í vinnu. Samtímis verða til milli þrjátíu og fj...
Feluleikur Samfylkingarinnar
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
Feluleikur Samfylkingarinnar
Feluleikur Samfylkingarinnar Fréttin30. júní 2026Björn Bjarnason, Innlent, StjórnmálLeave a Comment Heiða B. Hilmisdóttir og Dagur. B. Eggertsson, fv....
Þriggja ára dreng bjargað eftir sex daga í húsrústum í Venesúela
📅 30.06.2026 👁️ 1
Þriggja ára dreng bjargað eftir sex daga í húsrústum í Venesúela
Þriggja ára gömlum dreng var bjargað lifandi úr rústunum í höfuðborginni Caracas í dag, sex dögum eftir að tveir gríðarlega harðir jarðskjálftar riðu ...