Challenge over Met Police's use of live facial recognition lost

Challenge over Met Police's use of live facial recognition lost

Court challenge over Met Police's use of live facial recognition lost

Ella Kiplingand
Dominic Casciani,Home and Legal Correspondent
Getty Images A facial recognition system is deployed by the Metropolitan Police at Oxford Circus on May 13, 2025 in London, England. According to Metropolitan Police, live facial recognition (LFR) technology is used to find wanted criminals on watch-lists, detect and prevent crime, as well as to safeguard or identify vulnerable people. Critics of the technology have raised concerns over privacy issues on how the data will be stored and used. (Photo by Leon Neal/Getty Images)Getty Images
A facial recognition system deployed by the Met Police at Oxford Circus last summer

Privacy campaigners have lost a High Court challenge aimed at limiting the Metropolitan Police's use of live facial recognition technology.

Youth worker Shaun Thompson, and Silkie Carlo, director of campaign group Big Brother Watch, brought the challenge over concerns that facial recognition could be used arbitrarily or in a discriminatory way.

In a major victory for the continued roll-out of the technology, the High Court rejected claims that the Met Police had broken human rights and privacy law by scanning faces in public.

The force will continue to use the technology, with commissioner Sir Mark Rowley calling the ruling an "important victory for public safety".

Shaun Thompson has said he intends to appeal the decision.

Policing Minister Sarah Jones said: "I welcome today's ruling because there can be no true liberty when people live in fear of crime in their communities."

She added that facial recognition technology would be rolled out across the country with "record investment".

Law-abiding citizens have "nothing to fear" as the technology "only locates specifically wanted people", Jones said.

Scotland Yard deploys identifiable live facial recognition vans to selected locations around the capital.

Once set up - and marked with signage - the cameras are turned on and scan people walking through the chosen area, such as a busy high street. The images are instantly compared to a database of wanted criminals or missing people.

If a face does not match anyone on the database, the system deletes the image instantly.

If it finds a possible match, it alerts officers who then double-check the hit before deciding whether to stop the individual.

Big Brother Watch Shaun Thompson, a black man with a beard wearing a green coat and a large beaded necklace stands next to a white woman with long blond hair, wearing a grey coat. The pair are stood outside of The Royal Courts of Justice.Big Brother Watch
Shaun Thompson and Silkie Carlo brought the challenge to the High Court

One of the claimants, Thompson, was misidentified by live facial recognition technology.

In February 2024, he was stopped, detained and questioned by police in London after being matched by the technology with his brother, who, at the time, was on bail for a suspected violent offence.

Thompson said the experience was "shocking and unfair".

In their challenge, Thompson and Carlo argued that the use of the technology breaches the right to privacy outlined in the European Convention of Human Rights.

They argued that the rights to freedom of expression and freedom of assembly are also being breached, claiming that the "excessively broad" discretion afforded to officers had a "chilling effect" on the ability to protest.

Lawyers argued that the plans to mount permanent installations in the capital would make it "impossible" for Londoners to travel without their biometric data being taken and processed.

The team taking the challenge against live facial recognition had raised concerns that the technology would be deployed disproportionally "in areas of London which are lived in by ethnic minority communities".

Lord Justice Holgate and Mrs Justice Farbey said in the 74-page ruling that the "risk and potential scope for discrimination on grounds of race was no more than faintly asserted".

The judgment also stated that Thompson and Carlo's human rights had not been breached.

Met Police commissioner, Sir Mark Rowley, said the High Court ruling was a "significant and important victory for public safety".

He added: "The courts have confirmed our approach is lawful. The public supports its use. It works. And it helps us keep Londoners safe.

"The question is no longer whether we should use live facial recognition, it's why we would choose not to."

In response to the ruling, Thompson said: "No one should be treated like a criminal due to a computer error.

"I was compliant with the police but my bank cards and passport weren't enough to convince the police the facial recognition tech was wrong.

"It's like stop and search on steroids. It's clear the more widely this is used, the more innocent people like me risk being criminalised."

Plans set out by the Home Office in January will increase the number of vans from 10 to 50 and make them available to all forces across England and Wales.

According to the Met Police, 2,100 arrests have been made since the start of 2024 using the technology.

Last year, more than three million faces walked past the live facial recognition cameras and 12 false alerts were logged, with none leading to an arrest.

Listen to the best of BBC Radio London on Sounds and follow BBC London on Facebook, X and Instagram. Send your story ideas to hello.bbclondon@bbc.co.uk

#recognition #challenge #police #facial #over


Upprunaleg slóð:
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cq59x4vv954o?at_medium=RSS&at_campaign=rss

📰 Aðrar fréttir

Breivik sækir um reynslulausn eitt skiptið enn
📅 24.04.2026 22:35:28 👁️ 0

Breivik sækir um reynslulausn eitt skiptið enn

#reynslulausn#breivik#skiptið#sækir#eitt
Trump's envoys Witkoff and Kushner to fly to Pakistan for Iran talks
📅 24.04.2026 22:02:50 👁️ 0

Trump's envoys Witkoff and Kushner to fly to Pakistan for Iran talks

#pakistan#witkoff#kushner#envoys#trump
I'm A Celebrity crowns 'jungle legend' after eventful all-star series
📅 24.04.2026 21:36:57 👁️ 0

I'm A Celebrity crowns 'jungle legend' after eventful all-star series

#celebrity#eventful#crowns#jungle#legend
Netanjahú greindist með krabba­mein - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 21:32:07 👁️ 0

Netanjahú greindist með krabba­mein - Vísir

#krabbamein#netanjahú#greindist#vísir
„Þetta er svona íslensk aðferð, framkvæma fyrst og spyrja svo“
📅 24.04.2026 21:20:44 👁️ 0

„Þetta er svona íslensk aðferð, framkvæma fyrst og spyrja svo“

#framkvæma#íslensk#aðferð#spyrja#þetta
Fjölgar í hópi sak­borninga og ráðist í hús­leit - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 21:15:33 👁️ 0

Fjölgar í hópi sak­borninga og ráðist í hús­leit - Vísir

#sakborninga#fjölgar#húsleit#ráðist#vísir
Stjórnarandstaðan sakaði meirihlutann um blekkingar
📅 24.04.2026 20:30:17 👁️ 0

Stjórnarandstaðan sakaði meirihlutann um blekkingar

#stjórnarandstaðan#meirihlutann#blekkingar#sakaði
Íslendingar sviknir um milljónir á Kanarí - Tryggingafélag varar við læknastofu - DV
📅 24.04.2026 20:30:11 👁️ 0

Íslendingar sviknir um milljónir á Kanarí - Tryggingafélag varar við læknastofu - DV

#tryggingafélag#íslendingar#læknastofu#milljónir#sviknir
Mikill áhugi nemenda á kórsöng á Laugarvatni og á Selfossi
📅 24.04.2026 20:25:19 👁️ 0

Mikill áhugi nemenda á kórsöng á Laugarvatni og á Selfossi

#laugarvatni#selfossi#nemenda#kórsöng#mikill
Tólf lögreglumál vegna áreitni í garð starfsfólks
📅 24.04.2026 20:01:03 👁️ 0

Tólf lögreglumál vegna áreitni í garð starfsfólks

#lögreglumál#starfsfólks#áreitni#vegna#tólf
Nýtt myndband frá Aðalheiði: Ræðir ghosting og stefnumótaöpp
📅 24.04.2026 20:00:35 👁️ 0

Nýtt myndband frá Aðalheiði: Ræðir ghosting og stefnumótaöpp

#stefnumótaöpp#aðalheiði#myndband#ghosting#ræðir
„Við­reisn er í al­gjörri lykil­stöðu“ - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 19:56:58 👁️ 0

„Við­reisn er í al­gjörri lykil­stöðu“ - Vísir

#lykilstöðu#viðreisn#algjörri#vísir
Svíar hugfangnir af elgum í leiðangri
📅 24.04.2026 19:43:20 👁️ 0

Svíar hugfangnir af elgum í leiðangri

#hugfangnir#leiðangri#svíar#elgum
Oddvitaumræður í Hveragerði
📅 24.04.2026 19:37:58 👁️ 0

Oddvitaumræður í Hveragerði

#oddvitaumræður#hveragerði
Sendi­menn Trump fara á fund utan­ríkis­ráð­herra Írans á morgun - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 19:17:49 👁️ 0

Sendi­menn Trump fara á fund utan­ríkis­ráð­herra Írans á morgun - Vísir

#utanríkisráðherra#sendimenn#morgun#trump#írans
70-year-old man revived after drowning incident at beach in Costa Adeje
📅 24.04.2026 19:11:00 👁️ 0

70-year-old man revived after drowning incident at beach in Costa Adeje

#drowning#incident#revived#after#beach
Segist vera réttmætur eigandi Mosa og vera hafður fyrir rangri sök - DV
📅 24.04.2026 18:56:56 👁️ 0

Segist vera réttmætur eigandi Mosa og vera hafður fyrir rangri sök - DV

#réttmætur#eigandi#segist#hafður#rangri
The unexpected benefits of upgrading your Golf Bag
📅 24.04.2026 18:55:00 👁️ 0

The unexpected benefits of upgrading your Golf Bag

#unexpected#upgrading#benefits#your#golf
Sjálfstæðisflokkur tekur fram úr Samfylkingu í borginni
📅 24.04.2026 18:49:07 👁️ 0

Sjálfstæðisflokkur tekur fram úr Samfylkingu í borginni

#sjálfstæðisflokkur#samfylkingu#borginni#tekur#fram
Sonur Reiner sendir frá sér tilfinningaþrungna yfirlýsingu
📅 24.04.2026 18:31:50 👁️ 0

Sonur Reiner sendir frá sér tilfinningaþrungna yfirlýsingu

#tilfinningaþrungna#yfirlýsingu#reiner#sendir#sonur
Bilið á milli turnanna breikkar - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 18:31:45 👁️ 0

Bilið á milli turnanna breikkar - Vísir

#turnanna#breikkar#bilið#milli#vísir
Hluthafaspjallið | Viðtal við Jón Þorstein, forstjóra Beru – og ruglið í danska Berlingske
📅 24.04.2026 18:31:06 👁️ 0

Hluthafaspjallið | Viðtal við Jón Þorstein, forstjóra Beru – og ruglið í danska Berlingske

#hluthafaspjallið#berlingske#forstjóra#þorstein#viðtal
Vestur­lönd tali opin­skátt um fyrirætlað stríð við Rúss­land - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 18:30:09 👁️ 0

Vestur­lönd tali opin­skátt um fyrirætlað stríð við Rúss­land - Vísir

#vesturlönd#fyrirætlað#opinskátt#rússland#stríð
Channel 5 newsreader withdraws claims against Dan Walker
📅 24.04.2026 18:17:05 👁️ 0

Channel 5 newsreader withdraws claims against Dan Walker

#newsreader#withdraws#channel#against#claims
Oddvitaumræður í Borgarbyggð
📅 24.04.2026 18:10:03 👁️ 0

Oddvitaumræður í Borgarbyggð

#oddvitaumræður#borgarbyggð
Vendingar í borginni og tón­leikar í heima­húsum - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 18:05:44 👁️ 0

Vendingar í borginni og tón­leikar í heima­húsum - Vísir

#heimahúsum#vendingar#tónleikar#borginni#vísir
Director Rob Reiner's son Jake Reiner bares soul on how he found out his parents were dead
📅 24.04.2026 18:02:54 👁️ 0

Director Rob Reiner's son Jake Reiner bares soul on how he found out his parents were dead

#director#parents#reiner#bares#found
AENA take action to ease passport control queues for British arrivals
📅 24.04.2026 17:51:00 👁️ 0

AENA take action to ease passport control queues for British arrivals

#passport#arrivals#control#british#action
Sakamálarannsókn á hendur seðlabankastjóra felld niður
📅 24.04.2026 17:48:23 👁️ 1

Sakamálarannsókn á hendur seðlabankastjóra felld niður

#sakamálarannsókn#seðlabankastjóra#hendur#felld#niður
Evrópusambandið rannsakar meint brot Mandelsons meðan hann var viðskiptastjóri
📅 24.04.2026 17:39:00 👁️ 0

Evrópusambandið rannsakar meint brot Mandelsons meðan hann var viðskiptastjóri

#evrópusambandið#viðskiptastjóri#mandelsons#rannsakar#meint
Tveir af hverjum þremur á fjárhagsaðstoð í Reykjavík eru útlendingar - DV
📅 24.04.2026 17:30:53 👁️ 0

Tveir af hverjum þremur á fjárhagsaðstoð í Reykjavík eru útlendingar - DV

#fjárhagsaðstoð#útlendingar#reykjavík#hverjum#þremur
Fimm bíla á­rekstur á Reykja­nes­braut - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 17:28:01 👁️ 0

Fimm bíla á­rekstur á Reykja­nes­braut - Vísir

#reykjanesbraut#árekstur#vísir#fimm#bíla
Eva Margrét tekur við taumunum hjá ESJA Legal ehf. - DV
📅 24.04.2026 17:01:55 👁️ 0

Eva Margrét tekur við taumunum hjá ESJA Legal ehf. - DV

#taumunum#margrét#tekur#legal#esja
Fimm bíla árekstur á Reykjanesbraut
📅 24.04.2026 17:01:40 👁️ 0

Fimm bíla árekstur á Reykjanesbraut

#reykjanesbraut#árekstur#fimm#bíla
Nokkurra bíla árekstur á Reykjanesbraut
📅 24.04.2026 17:01:40 👁️ 0

Nokkurra bíla árekstur á Reykjanesbraut

#reykjanesbraut#nokkurra#árekstur#bíla
Nútíma óligarkinn – Kristján Arason, Centra ráðgjöf og skatta undanskotin
📅 24.04.2026 16:57:35 👁️ 0

Nútíma óligarkinn – Kristján Arason, Centra ráðgjöf og skatta undanskotin

#undanskotin#óligarkinn#kristján#ráðgjöf#nútíma
Lista­verkið muni auka öryggi og vernda náttúruna á svæðinu - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 16:55:31 👁️ 0

Lista­verkið muni auka öryggi og vernda náttúruna á svæðinu - Vísir

#listaverkið#náttúruna#svæðinu#öryggi#vernda
Tveir helstu samningamenn Bandaríkjanna á leið til fundar við utanríkisráðherra Írans
📅 24.04.2026 16:47:29 👁️ 0

Tveir helstu samningamenn Bandaríkjanna á leið til fundar við utanríkisráðherra Írans

#utanríkisráðherra#bandaríkjanna#samningamenn#helstu#fundar
Orrustuþotur höfðu afskipti af rússneskum herþotum innan lofthelginnar
📅 24.04.2026 16:47:16 👁️ 1

Orrustuþotur höfðu afskipti af rússneskum herþotum innan lofthelginnar

#lofthelginnar#orrustuþotur#rússneskum#afskipti#herþotum
Dagur segir enga hættu felast í því að láta reyna á samninga við ESB - DV
📅 24.04.2026 16:30:53 👁️ 0

Dagur segir enga hættu felast í því að láta reyna á samninga við ESB - DV

#samninga#felast#dagur#segir#hættu
Hegseth segir Írana hafa sögulegt tækifæri til samkomulags við Bandaríkin
📅 24.04.2026 16:20:33 👁️ 0

Hegseth segir Írana hafa sögulegt tækifæri til samkomulags við Bandaríkin

#samkomulags#bandaríkin#sögulegt#tækifæri#hegseth
Israeli police investigate after officers 'cut Palestinian flag' from skullcap
📅 24.04.2026 16:20:10 👁️ 0

Israeli police investigate after officers 'cut Palestinian flag' from skullcap

#investigate#palestinian#officers#skullcap#israeli
Mandelson under formal investigation by EU's anti-fraud office
📅 24.04.2026 16:18:19 👁️ 0

Mandelson under formal investigation by EU's anti-fraud office

#investigation#mandelson#formal#office#under
Sinueldur kviknaði við bensín­stöð - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 16:13:48 👁️ 0

Sinueldur kviknaði við bensín­stöð - Vísir

#bensínstöð#sinueldur#kviknaði#vísir
Horfðu til himins
📅 24.04.2026 16:10:00 👁️ 0

Horfðu til himins

#horfðu#himins
Segir leik Snorra í High School Musical fyrirboða
📅 24.04.2026 16:08:00 👁️ 0

Segir leik Snorra í High School Musical fyrirboða

#fyrirboða#musical#snorra#school#segir
Sinueldur við N1 í Fossvogi
📅 24.04.2026 15:56:06 👁️ 0

Sinueldur við N1 í Fossvogi

#sinueldur#fossvogi
Starfsfólk N1 slökkti sinueld skammt frá bensínstöðinni
📅 24.04.2026 15:56:06 👁️ 0

Starfsfólk N1 slökkti sinueld skammt frá bensínstöðinni

#bensínstöðinni#starfsfólk#slökkti#sinueld#skammt
Leikskólapláss losna óvænt í Vesturbænum
📅 24.04.2026 15:53:12 👁️ 0

Leikskólapláss losna óvænt í Vesturbænum

#leikskólapláss#vesturbænum#losna#óvænt
Tveir Íslendingar týndir á erlendri grundu í níu mánuði
📅 24.04.2026 15:33:25 👁️ 0

Tveir Íslendingar týndir á erlendri grundu í níu mánuði

#íslendingar#erlendri#týndir#grundu#mánuði