What is a 'safe death'? Mentally ill woman asks for assisted dying in Canada

What is a 'safe death'? Mentally ill woman asks for assisted dying in Canada

What is a 'safe death'? Mentally ill woman asks for assisted dying in Canada

Claire Brosseau has travelled the world doing stand-up comedy and acting in television shows, films and plays. She has also been struggling with debilitating mental illness from a young age, and has been treated by psychiatrists in four major North American cities over three decades.

Brosseau has tried nearly every treatment available to people like herself with bipolar disorder and PTSD, she said, from behavioural therapy and medication to electric shocks to the brain.

Nothing has worked for the 49-year-old Toronto woman, who described herself as "functionally terminal", no longer able to work, leave the house or speak with her loved ones. She is now enrolled in a psychiatric care programme at a local hospital that, she said, is designed to support people with severe and persistent mental illness who have exhausted all treatment options.

"There's nothing left to try, and I'm at the end of my life," she told the BBC.

Brosseau wants to die by medically assisted dying, also known as euthanasia and in Canada, under the acronym MAID. While it is legal in Canada, it is not currently available to those whose sole condition is mental illness.

"I open my eyes every morning and I feel immediate dread and anxiety," Brosseau said, adding: "I want a safe death. I don't want to have to do something horrific."

Canada has been planning to expand the law to people with severe, treatment-resistant mental illness, but has delayed doing so twice - most recently to next year - over concerns the healthcare system is not prepared. Now, Ottawa is weighing whether to move forward at all.

In the meantime, Brosseau said her illness is worsening and she cannot afford to wait any longer. She has asked an Ontario court to exempt her from the current law and grant her access to medically assisted dying.

Polls suggest the majority of Canadians support access to medically assisted death. But the issue has been more fraught when discussing patients with mental illness.

Over the past two months, a parliamentary committee tasked with reviewing whether Canada should expand the programme heard from advocates and medical experts who warned against doing so.

Some argue that assisted dying has, in some cases, become a tool to alleviate suffering of disabled Canadians who would be better served by improved access to affordable housing, healthcare and disability supports.

Others argued that mental illnesses are not yet well understood by medicine, making it difficult to determine if a patient is expressing suicidal ideation or is indeed incurable.

Dr Sonu Gaind, a former chief of psychiatry at a major Toronto hospital, told the committee that "none of those issues have been resolved" since Canada decided to pause its expansion to assisted dying.

"Instead, we have even more evidence showing we are not ready to provide MAID for mental illness," he said.

What the committee recommends could ultimately shape the programme's future. Prime Minister Mark Carney told reporters last week that he is waiting for their report before deciding on next steps. "I like to take informed positions," he said.

For Brosseau, the refusal to grant assisted death to psychiatric patients is rooted in stigma, with physical illnesses viewed as more legitimate.

"If I get cancer tomorrow, I can refuse treatment and be eligible for MAID," she said. But patients with severe mental illnesses, she argued, aren't granted the same access to what has become a standardised part of Canadian healthcare.

That position is at the core of the legal case brought by Brosseau, which argues that current laws are exclusionary to those with mental illness and therefore unconstitutional.

Canada is one of a handful of countries where assisted dying is legal for both terminally ill patients and those whose death is not "reasonably foreseeable" but who have an irreversible serious illness, disease or disability.

A few, namely the Netherlands, Belgium and Luxembourg, allow access to people who are suffering solely from a mental illness.

The Netherlands is in the midst of its own heated public debate on assisted dying, which has spilled into the Canadian committee hearings.

Those seeking assisted death for a mental illness in the Netherlands have to be assessed by a psychiatrist. Data shows that approvals for psychiatric suffering are relatively rare, accounting for about 2% of all deaths by assisted dying in the country. But the overall number of approved cases has risen, from two in 2010 to 219 in 2024.

One Dutch psychiatrist, Dr Jim van Os, told Canadian lawmakers that the increase in cases reflects what he described as a "suicide contagion effect".

"The Dutch experience in my opinion offers a warning for Canada," Os cautioned.

Another Dutch psychiatrist, Dr Sisco Van Veen, countered that assisted dying for psychiatric patients remains rare and that MAID offers "mercy" for those "whose suffering can be immense or unbearable".

In Canada, about 96% of assisted-dying requests in 2024 were granted to people whose death was forseeable - mostly terminal cancer patients. The remaining 4% are patients whose death was not imminent but had a "grievous and irremediable medical condition".

Canada extended assisted dying to patients who were not terminally ill five years ago, after two people with disabilities mounted a legal battle for access to the programme.

That move has been controversial, and is one of the reasons driving opposition to further expansion.

Advocacy groups have reported cases where assisted dying has been offered to people with disabilities by healthcare or support workers without the patient requesting it themselves.

"We are investing in ending people's lives" rather than in offering them a better quality of life, said Krista Orr, president of disability advocacy group Inclusion Canada,

She, too, testified before the committee, urging lawmakers not only to not expand MAID to people with mental illness but to limit it once again solely to people with a terminal illness.

There has also been criticism of the committee itself. Brosseau, for one, said she is troubled by how the hearings unfolded and who was called to testify. She said she requested to appear multiple times but was refused.

She noted that the co-chairs of the committee - Liberal MP Marcus Powlowski and Conservative Senator Yonah Martin - have both publicly voiced opposition to expanding MAID.

One member, Alberta Senator Kristopher Wells, has publicly accused the review of being "one-sided", telling the Toronto Star newspaper that he does not have confidence in the final report.

In a statement to the BBC, the committee co-chairs acknowledged that Brosseau had asked to testify, but said evidence from professionals and associations was proritised due to "limited time".

Powlowski also defended the committee against accusations of bias, telling the Star that members have "dutifully listened to both sides".

Their report could be presented to parliament as late as October.

Brosseau said she does not have faith in the committee, its report or the federal government, which has yet to respond to her legal challenge.

She rarely leaves her home. Even a trip to the store can trigger extreme stress and panic attacks, she said. But she said she viewed her legal fight as an important one for equal rights.

"I'm not campaigning for death. I'm campaigning to be seen as not a subsection of human," she said.

Toronto Star via Getty Images Claire Brosseau is photographed at her home in Toronto, Canada. She has dark brown hair and blue eyes. She is seated at a table with her arms crossed. She is wearing a brown short-sleeved turtle neck.
Getty Images An image showing Carney speaking at a trades event. He has short grey and black hair and blue eyes. He is wearing a black suit with a light blue shirt and a navy blue dotted tie.
PA Media An image showing protestors both for and against assisted dying in the UK. One holds a sign that says
#death #ill #mentally #safe #what


Upprunaleg slóð:
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c78qzpg0n0go?at_medium=RSS&at_campaign=rss

📰 Aðrar fréttir

Foreldrasamtök svara bæjarfulltrúa – „Líkamleg og andleg heilsa barna okkar er ekki til sölu fyrir atkvæði“
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 1
Foreldrasamtök svara bæjarfulltrúa – „Líkamleg og andleg heilsa barna okkar er ekki til sölu fyrir atkvæði“
Foreldrasamtök svara bæjarfulltrúa – „Líkamleg og andleg heilsa barna okkar er ekki til sölu fyrir atkvæði“ ForsíðaFréttir Tweet Ína og Víðir svara Gu...
Súld fyrir sunnan en sólríkt fyrir norðan á kjördag
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Súld fyrir sunnan en sólríkt fyrir norðan á kjördag
Lægð á Grænlandshafi hefur áhrif á veður og vinda þegar gengið verður til kosninga um allt land í dag. Sunnan- og vestanlands verður suðaustanátt á bi...
Sungið með Sinfó á Skaganum
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Sungið með Sinfó á Skaganum
Sinfóníuhljómsveit Íslands hélt tvenna tónleika á Akranesi í gær. Hátt í 190 söngvarar tóku þátt í tónleikum hljómsveitarinnar í kvöld sem er einhver ...
Scuba diver fighting for her life after incident in Lanzarote
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Scuba diver fighting for her life after incident in Lanzarote
A female scuba diver is fighting for her life in Lanzarote after suffering a cardiac arrest during a dive on Friday afternoon. The incident happened a...
Rússlandsforseti heimsækir Kínaforseta fast á hæla Bandaríkjaforseta
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Rússlandsforseti heimsækir Kínaforseta fast á hæla Bandaríkjaforseta
Vladimír Pútín Rússlandsforseti fetar í næstu viku í fótspor Donalds Trump Bandaríkjaforseta og heimsækir Xi Jinping Kínaforseta. Samkvæmt tilkynningu...
Utanríkisráðuneytið áréttar fullveldi og sjálfstæði
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 1
Utanríkisráðuneytið áréttar fullveldi og sjálfstæði
Stjórnvöld á Taívan sáu sig knúin til að árétta eigið sjálfstæði nokkrum klukkustundum eftir að Donald Trump Bandaríkjaforseti kvaðst andvígur því að ...
Kosningavaktin 2026: Kjör­dagur genginn í garð - Vísir
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Kosningavaktin 2026: Kjör­dagur genginn í garð - Vísir
Kosningavakt Vísis verður lifandi frá morgni kjördags og inn í næstu viku, eftir þörfum. Klukkan 20 hefst Gott kosningakvöld með þeim Benna og Fannari...
Þjóðvegur 66: „Sennilega ekki til betra ferðalag.“
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Þjóðvegur 66: „Sennilega ekki til betra ferðalag.“
Jón nokkur Steinbeckhann fór þessa slóðog hann skrifaði skrudduum undarlega þjóð.Um fólk í nauðumsem leitaði að náð,mætti fjandskap,allt þetta er skrá...
78% drop in migrant arrivals by boat in the Canary Islands so far in 2026
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
78% drop in migrant arrivals by boat in the Canary Islands so far in 2026
Irregular migrant arrivals to the Canary Islands have fallen dramatically this year, according to the latest statistics from Frontex, who have reporte...
Hálffertugur karlmaður látinn eftir árás hákarls
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 1
Hálffertugur karlmaður látinn eftir árás hákarls
Karlmaður á fertugsaldri er látinn eftir að hvítháfur réðst á hann í hafinu við áströlsku borgina Perth. Björgunarsveitir og þyrla voru send manninum ...
r/Iceland leggur í einelti
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 5
r/Iceland leggur í einelti
Meintur "Stuðningshópur íslendinga" á vefsvæðinu reddit.com virðist fara hamförum í því að hafna öllum stuðningi við því sem bara sumir hafa áhuga á a...
Sunshine returns across much of the Canary Islands this Saturday
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Sunshine returns across much of the Canary Islands this Saturday
The Canary Islands are set for a mainly bright and settled Saturday, with plenty of sunshine expected across much of the archipelago, although some cl...
Óttar Guðmundsson skrifar: Narsissisminn - DV
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Óttar Guðmundsson skrifar: Narsissisminn - DV
Í grísku goðafræðinni er sagt frá hinum íðilfagra konungssyni Narsissusi. Skógardísin Ekkó varð ástfangin af piltinum en sú ást var ekki endurgoldin. ...
Trump warns Taiwan against declaring independence after China talks
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Trump warns Taiwan against declaring independence after China talks
US President Donald Trump has cautioned Taiwan against formally declaring independence from China."I'm not looking to have somebody go independent," t...
Næstæðsti leiðtogi ISIS sagður felldur í þaulskipulagðri aðgerð
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Næstæðsti leiðtogi ISIS sagður felldur í þaulskipulagðri aðgerð
Abu-Bilal al-Minuki, næstæðsti leiðtogi hryðjuverkasamtakanna sem kenna sig við íslamskt ríki, er sagður hafa verið veginn í Nígeríu, að fyrirskipun D...
Nýjustu tölur í Reykja­vík - Vísir
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Nýjustu tölur í Reykja­vík - Vísir
Eftir sveitarstjórnarkosningarnar 2022 mynduðu Samfylking, Framsókn, Píratar og Viðreisn meirihluta en fyrir rúmu ári sleit Framsókn samstarfinu og va...
Nýjustu tölur í Kópa­vogi - Vísir
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Nýjustu tölur í Kópa­vogi - Vísir
Eftir bæjarstjórnarkosningarnar árið 2022 héldu Sjálfstæðisflokkurinn og Framsóknarflokkurinn áfram meirihlutasamstarfi sínu. Ásdís Kristjánsdóttir Sj...
Nýjustu tölur í Hafnar­firði - Vísir
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Nýjustu tölur í Hafnar­firði - Vísir
Eftir bæjarstjórnarkosningarnar árið 2022 héldu Sjálfstæðisflokkurinn og Framsóknarflokkurinn áfram meirihlutasamstarfi sínu.  Rósa Guðbjartsdóttir Sj...
Nýjustu tölur úr Garða­bæ - Vísir
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Nýjustu tölur úr Garða­bæ - Vísir
Eftir bæjarstjórnarkosningarnar árið 2022 var Sjálfstæðisflokkurinn áfram með hreinan meirihluta í sveitarstjórn þrátt fyrir að hafa þá misst einn man...
Nýjustu tölur á Akur­eyri - Vísir
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Nýjustu tölur á Akur­eyri - Vísir
Eftir bæjarstjórnarkosningarnar árið 2022 mynduðu fulltrúar L-lista, Sjálfstæðisflokks og Miðflokks meirihluta og var Ásthildur Sturludóttir ráðin í e...
Nýjustu tölur í Reykja­nes­bæ - Vísir
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Nýjustu tölur í Reykja­nes­bæ - Vísir
Eftir bæjarstjórnarkosningarnar árið 2022 mynduðu Framsókn, Samfylking og Bein leið nýjan meirihluta. Kjartan Már Kjartansson hélt áfram störfum sem r...
Nýjustu tölur í Ár­borg - Vísir
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Nýjustu tölur í Ár­borg - Vísir
Eftir bæjarstjórnarkosningarnar árið 2022 var Sjálfstæðisflokkurinn með hreinan meirihluta og tók bæjarfulltrúinn Fjóla Kristinsdóttir við embætti bæj...
Nýjustu tölur í Mos­fells­bæ - Vísir
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Nýjustu tölur í Mos­fells­bæ - Vísir
Eftir bæjarstjórnarkosningarnar árið 2022 mynduðu Framsóknarflokkurinn, Samfylkingin og Viðreisn meirihluta og var Regína Ásvaldsdóttir ráðin bæjarstj...
Nýjustu tölur á Akra­nesi - Vísir
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 2
Nýjustu tölur á Akra­nesi - Vísir
Eftir bæjarstjórnarkosningarnar árið 2022 mynduðu Samfylking og Sjálfstæðisflokkur meirihluta þar sem Sævar Freyr Þráinsson var ráðinn til að gegna áf...
Hvar og hvenær og hvernig skal nú kosið?
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Hvar og hvenær og hvernig skal nú kosið?
Kjörstaðir fyrir sveitarstjórnarkosningarnar í dag verða yfirleitt opnaðir klukkan níu og þeim lokað klukkan tíu í kvöld. Það er þó ekki alveg algilt....
Vopnahlé Ísraels og Líbanons framlengt um 45 daga
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Vopnahlé Ísraels og Líbanons framlengt um 45 daga
Samkomulag hefur náðst milli Ísraelsríkis og Líbanon um að framlengja vopnahlé milli landanna um einn og hálfan mánuð.Vopnahléi sem hófst um miðjan ap...
Bandarískum hermönnum verður ekki fjölgað í Póllandi
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Bandarískum hermönnum verður ekki fjölgað í Póllandi
Bandaríkjastjórn hefur hætt við áform um að senda fjögur þúsund hermenn til Póllands. Christopher LaNeve, starfandi herráðsforingi, greindi frá þessu ...
Trump andvígur því að Taívan lýsi yfir sjálfstæði
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Trump andvígur því að Taívan lýsi yfir sjálfstæði
Donald Trump Bandaríkjaforseti hefur varað stjórnvöld á Taívan við því að lýsa formlega yfir sjálfstæði. „Ég leitast ekki eftir því að einhver gerist ...
Judge declares another mistrial in Harvey Weinstein New York rape charge
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Judge declares another mistrial in Harvey Weinstein New York rape charge
A judge has declared a mistrial in the rape case against Harvey Weinstein, after the jury in New York said it was deadlocked and unable to reach a ver...
Minnst sjö drepnir í loftárás Ísraelshers
📅 16.05.2026 👁️ 0
Minnst sjö drepnir í loftárás Ísraelshers
Að minnsta kosti sjö Palestínumenn voru drepnir í loftárás Ísraelshers á Gaza í kvöld, þar á meðal minnst eitt barn, samkvæmt upplýsingum heilbrigðisy...
Lebanon says six killed in Israeli strike as US announces ceasefire extension
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
Lebanon says six killed in Israeli strike as US announces ceasefire extension
An Israeli air strike on a town in southern Lebanon has killed six people, including three paramedics, according to Lebanon's health ministry. It come...
Sjálfstæðisflokkur mælist stærstur í nýrri könnun Maskínu
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
Sjálfstæðisflokkur mælist stærstur í nýrri könnun Maskínu
Sjálfstæðisflokkurinn mælist með mest fylgi allra stjórnmálaflokka í Reykjavík í glænýrri skoðanakönnun Maskínu. Flokkurinn mælist með 31,3 prósent se...
I tried the Gail's 'saltiest' sandwich in the UK
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 1
I tried the Gail's 'saltiest' sandwich in the UK
I couldn't resist. This week it was revealed a chicken sandwich is packing as much salt as five McDonald's cheeseburgers - putting it top of a naughty...
Labour allows Andy Burnham to run for selection in pivotal by-election
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
Labour allows Andy Burnham to run for selection in pivotal by-election
Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham has been cleared to seek selection as Labour's candidate in a by-election which could pave the way for him to re...
'They took £20,000 I didn't owe': Parents hit by Child Maintenance Service errors
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
'They took £20,000 I didn't owe': Parents hit by Child Maintenance Service errors
Maths teacher John Hammond was a few weeks into his job at a new school, chatting to colleagues in the staff room during lunch break. He decided to ch...
Áhorfendum fannst Hildur standa sig langbest í kappræðunum
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
Áhorfendum fannst Hildur standa sig langbest í kappræðunum
Hildur Björnsdóttir, oddviti Sjálfstæðisflokksins, stóð sig best í kappræðum kvöldsins á RÚV að mati áhorfenda, sem greiddu atkvæði með smáforritinu R...
Eurovision final: Sex, violins and seven other things to look out for
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
Eurovision final: Sex, violins and seven other things to look out for
The Eurovision Song Contest reaches its grand final on Saturday night, with Finland, Greece and Australia among the favourites to win.The show is taki...
Josef Mengele: Switzerland finally to open secret files on Nazis' Auschwitz 'Angel of Death'
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
Josef Mengele: Switzerland finally to open secret files on Nazis' Auschwitz 'Angel of Death'
The Swiss Federal Intelligence Service has said it will finally open long-sealed files on the notorious Nazi war criminal Josef Mengele, but without s...
Faðir stúlku sem varð fyrir einelti skaut á bíl gerendanna - „Ég held að allir skilji reiði hans“ - DV
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
Faðir stúlku sem varð fyrir einelti skaut á bíl gerendanna - „Ég held að allir skilji reiði hans“ - DV
Faðir í Kaliforníu hefur verið ákærður fyrir að skjóta að unglingspiltum sem voru að leggja dóttur hans í einelti. Drengirnir köstuðu eggjum í heimili...
„Ég veit ekki al­veg hvernig stendur á þessu“ - Vísir
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 2
„Ég veit ekki al­veg hvernig stendur á þessu“ - Vísir
„Það var bara allt afturkallað. Þetta reyndist ekki vera neitt,“ segir Pálmi Hlöðversson varðstjóri. Enginn reykur hafi verið sjáanlegur á staðnum. „E...
Fyrstu tölur muni lík­lega detta í hús eftir mið­nætti - Vísir
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 2
Fyrstu tölur muni lík­lega detta í hús eftir mið­nætti - Vísir
Á annað hundrað manns verða í ÍR-heimilinu á morgun að telja atkvæði en í kvöldfréttum Sýnar var rætt við Evu Bryndísi Helgadóttur, formann yfirkjörst...
Tókust á um fjölda borgar­full­trúa - Vísir
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 2
Tókust á um fjölda borgar­full­trúa - Vísir
Þetta er meðal þess sem kom fram í kappræðum oddvita á Sýn. Þar voru frambjóðendur beðnir um að taka afstöðu með já og nei skiltum til málefna. Meðal ...
Five Italians die during cave scuba dive in Maldives
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
Five Italians die during cave scuba dive in Maldives
Five Italians have died in a scuba diving accident in the Maldives, the foreign ministry in Rome has said."The divers are believed to have died while ...
Hjartaskurðlæknir varar við mat sem margir borða daglega: „Eyðileggur hjartað hægt og rólega“ - DV
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
Hjartaskurðlæknir varar við mat sem margir borða daglega: „Eyðileggur hjartað hægt og rólega“ - DV
Hjartaskurðlæknirinn Philip Ovadia, sem hefur framkvæmt yfir 3.000 hjartaaðgerðir á ferlinum, hefur varað við algengum matvælum sem hann segir eiga st...
Hvorki eldur né reykur þegar slökkvilið mætti
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
Hvorki eldur né reykur þegar slökkvilið mætti
Slökkvilið fékk tilkynningu eftir klukkan 21 um eld í ruslageymslu í Breiðholti en þegar slökkviliðsmenn mættu á staðinn var hvorki reykur né eldur.Sl...
Twenty years enough for Iran nuclear suspension, says Trump
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
Twenty years enough for Iran nuclear suspension, says Trump
US President Donald Trump has said he would accept a 20-year suspension by Iran of its nuclear programme, in what appears to be confirmation of a shif...
Tók debet­kort af vitskertum vistmanni og eyddi rúmri milljón - Vísir
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 4
Tók debet­kort af vitskertum vistmanni og eyddi rúmri milljón - Vísir
Málið var höfðað með ákæru lögreglustjórans á Vestfjörðum í febrúar síðastliðnum en konan starfaði sem ummönnunaraðili á hjúkrunar- og dvalarheimilinu...
British firm vying to build next Red Arrows jets goes into administration
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
British firm vying to build next Red Arrows jets goes into administration
A British aerospace company that was developing a replacement for the famous Red Arrows fighter jet has gone into administration, resulting in the los...
Alleged murder of Aboriginal girl highlights Australia's deep inequalities
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 0
Alleged murder of Aboriginal girl highlights Australia's deep inequalities
Warning for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander readers: this article contains references to and images of someone who has died. This note has been ...
Sjálf­stæðis­flokkurinn feginn eftir ára­tuga­langa eyði­merkur­göngu - Vísir
📅 15.05.2026 👁️ 2
Sjálf­stæðis­flokkurinn feginn eftir ára­tuga­langa eyði­merkur­göngu - Vísir
Magnús Sigurbjörnsson, hlaðvarpsstjórnandi og fyrrverandi framkvæmdastjóri borgarstjórnarhóps Sjálfstæðisflokksins, og Pétur Krogh Ólafsson, hlaðvarps...