A grim week for Keir Starmer – but things could be about to get worse

A grim week for Keir Starmer – but things could be about to get worse

A grim week for Starmer – but things could be about to get worse

Chris MasonPolitical editor
PA Media Sir Keir StarmerPA Media

This was the week questions about the future of the prime minister took a turn for the worse for Sir Keir Starmer.

If you had asked me a fortnight ago about the sentiment we were picking up from Labour MPs about Sir Keir's future in Downing Street, I would have told you that pressure from them appeared to have eased.

Perhaps, some pondered, after the prime minister's political near death experience in February - the moment the Energy Secretary Ed Miliband said the party "looked over the precipice" - the appetite to take another peek over the edge had gone, at least for now.

Labour MPs were still looking towards the elections around Britain a week on Thursday with trepidation bordering on horror, but many talked with pride about how their leader was handling the war in the Middle East and the fervent leadership chatter had eased, at least a bit.

But all of this was before mid-afternoon on Thursday of last week, when the Guardian's investigation about Lord Mandelson's security vetting dropped.

Since then, an unremittingly, relentlessly, incessantly grim story, if you think of it from the perspective of the Labour Party, has been squatting on the news agenda, expelling the potential for anything they would rather be talking about getting any attention.

And yes, just days before those crucial elections to the Scottish and Welsh parliaments and to many English local authorities.

So you won't be remotely surprised when I tell you that it has left Labour folk from the cabinet down gloomy, run down and irritated.

We have seen an element of that play out publicly.

Ministers deployed on what is known as the morning round, where they trundle from one studio to the next, often in possession of a government announcement but also braced for an avalanche of questions on the story of the day, haven't hidden their frustrations as assiduously as they might once have done.

The aforementioned Miliband, a former party leader, acknowledged on Sky News that when Lord Mandelson was appointed to the ambassador's job in Washington he had worried "it could blow up" and he had discussed those concerns with cabinet colleague David Lammy, who he said shared them.

What is telling is less that that was his view at the time, and more that it is something he is willing to share publicly now.

He also said, on Good Morning Britain, that it was "a fair point" that enough was already known about Lord Mandelson when he got the job that it would have been possible to conclude at the time that his appointment was not just risky but wrong.

Later in the week it was the turn of Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden to head from camera to camera.

He is, usually, a doughty defender of the government and he still was.

But he was managing to put a noticeable distance between himself and the news No 10 had been hawking their former director of communications Lord Doyle for a job as an ambassador.

Foreign Secretary Yvette Cooper went further – she was publicly aghast at this particular revelation.

Each example here felt to me like straws in the wind – easily dismissed in isolation but alongside everything else an indicator of the prime minister's declining authority.

Then there was this week's cabinet meeting, where ministers were happy to let it be known to journalists that they had expressed concern about the government's relationship with the Civil Service, after the unceremonious dumping of the top official at the Foreign Office, Sir Olly Robbins.

Chancellor Rachel Reeves and Health Secretary Wes Streeting were among those who spoke up on this.

There is nuance here - the prime minister himself had expressed concern too, we are told.

And of course cabinet ministers will fret about this - they deal daily with their permanent secretary and senior civil servants and rely on them to deliver their agenda.

But again, and yes it's subtle, there was a willingness to let it be known the consequences of No 10's actions had been raised.

Reuters Sir Keir Starmer smiles alongside Lord Mandelson at the UK ambassador's residence in Washington DC.Reuters
The row over the appointment of Lord Mandelson, pictured here with the PM last year, has blown up again over the past week

We then had Labour backbencher Jonathan Brash telling GB News Sir Keir's time was up and his colleague Dan Carden on BBC Newsnight being a little less blunt but nonetheless saying "there is definitely a question about the future of the Labour government."

The left-wing political magazine the New Statesman chimed in too. Its editor, Tom McTague, a thoughtful writer not known for hyperbole, said of Sir Keir: "The clamour is growing: he cannot do the job."

His article quoted Boris Johnson's public reflection when the time was up for him in Downing Street, when he said "when the herd moves it moves".

It was a reference to his parliamentary party, the crucial electorate for any party leader: it is their MPs who decide their fate.

And this week, the Labour herd is chuntering; it is chewing the leadership cud again.

It is worth reflecting that the fundamentals that brought about Labour's big wobble over Sir Keir in February are still there, as are the fundamentals that meant he survived that moment.

Let's take each in turn: the government is deeply unpopular and Sir Keir is more so.

This, alongside the evergreen critique made of this government, by those on its own side and its opponents, that it lacks a clear sense of direction and purpose, is the fundamental that makes Labour folk ponder how long he should have left.

But there is another fundamental too. The party cannot agree who it would like to replace him and plenty of the leading candidates have tricky things to overcome.

The former Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner is still in a wrangle with the taxman.

The mayor of Greater Manchester Andy Burnham isn't an MP.

And Streeting, the health secretary, is trying to shake off his connection and previous friendship with Lord Mandelson.

The prospect of a leadership race, while in office, horrifies many Labour MPs because critics would label it self-indulgent and navel-gazing – and it would deliver a new prime minister with no mandate from the electorate.

It feels then something like that classic philosophical paradox of an immovable object encountering an unstoppable force: logically impossible because the existence of one precludes the other.

So far at least, the fundamentals standing in the way of toppling the prime minister have proved stronger than those arguing for change.

The huge question now is whether that changes when the Labour Party confronts the likely grizzly reality of the electorate's verdict early next month.

Thin, red banner promoting the Politics Essential newsletter with text saying, “Top political analysis in your inbox every day”. There is also an image of the Houses of Parliament.

Sign up for our Politics Essential newsletter to keep up with the inner workings of Westminster and beyond.

#starmer #things #could #about #worse


Upprunaleg slóð:
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cvg423lnlp5o?at_medium=RSS&at_campaign=rss

📰 Aðrar fréttir

Breivik sækir um reynslulausn eitt skiptið enn
📅 24.04.2026 22:35:28 👁️ 0

Breivik sækir um reynslulausn eitt skiptið enn

#reynslulausn#breivik#skiptið#sækir#eitt
Trump's envoys Witkoff and Kushner to fly to Pakistan for Iran talks
📅 24.04.2026 22:02:50 👁️ 0

Trump's envoys Witkoff and Kushner to fly to Pakistan for Iran talks

#pakistan#witkoff#kushner#envoys#trump
I'm A Celebrity crowns 'jungle legend' after eventful all-star series
📅 24.04.2026 21:36:57 👁️ 0

I'm A Celebrity crowns 'jungle legend' after eventful all-star series

#celebrity#eventful#crowns#jungle#legend
Netanjahú greindist með krabba­mein - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 21:32:07 👁️ 0

Netanjahú greindist með krabba­mein - Vísir

#krabbamein#netanjahú#greindist#vísir
„Þetta er svona íslensk aðferð, framkvæma fyrst og spyrja svo“
📅 24.04.2026 21:20:44 👁️ 0

„Þetta er svona íslensk aðferð, framkvæma fyrst og spyrja svo“

#framkvæma#íslensk#aðferð#spyrja#þetta
Fjölgar í hópi sak­borninga og ráðist í hús­leit - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 21:15:33 👁️ 0

Fjölgar í hópi sak­borninga og ráðist í hús­leit - Vísir

#sakborninga#fjölgar#húsleit#ráðist#vísir
Stjórnarandstaðan sakaði meirihlutann um blekkingar
📅 24.04.2026 20:30:17 👁️ 0

Stjórnarandstaðan sakaði meirihlutann um blekkingar

#stjórnarandstaðan#meirihlutann#blekkingar#sakaði
Íslendingar sviknir um milljónir á Kanarí - Tryggingafélag varar við læknastofu - DV
📅 24.04.2026 20:30:11 👁️ 0

Íslendingar sviknir um milljónir á Kanarí - Tryggingafélag varar við læknastofu - DV

#tryggingafélag#íslendingar#læknastofu#milljónir#sviknir
Mikill áhugi nemenda á kórsöng á Laugarvatni og á Selfossi
📅 24.04.2026 20:25:19 👁️ 0

Mikill áhugi nemenda á kórsöng á Laugarvatni og á Selfossi

#laugarvatni#selfossi#nemenda#kórsöng#mikill
Tólf lögreglumál vegna áreitni í garð starfsfólks
📅 24.04.2026 20:01:03 👁️ 0

Tólf lögreglumál vegna áreitni í garð starfsfólks

#lögreglumál#starfsfólks#áreitni#vegna#tólf
Nýtt myndband frá Aðalheiði: Ræðir ghosting og stefnumótaöpp
📅 24.04.2026 20:00:35 👁️ 0

Nýtt myndband frá Aðalheiði: Ræðir ghosting og stefnumótaöpp

#stefnumótaöpp#aðalheiði#myndband#ghosting#ræðir
„Við­reisn er í al­gjörri lykil­stöðu“ - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 19:56:58 👁️ 0

„Við­reisn er í al­gjörri lykil­stöðu“ - Vísir

#lykilstöðu#viðreisn#algjörri#vísir
Svíar hugfangnir af elgum í leiðangri
📅 24.04.2026 19:43:20 👁️ 0

Svíar hugfangnir af elgum í leiðangri

#hugfangnir#leiðangri#svíar#elgum
Oddvitaumræður í Hveragerði
📅 24.04.2026 19:37:58 👁️ 0

Oddvitaumræður í Hveragerði

#oddvitaumræður#hveragerði
Sendi­menn Trump fara á fund utan­ríkis­ráð­herra Írans á morgun - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 19:17:49 👁️ 0

Sendi­menn Trump fara á fund utan­ríkis­ráð­herra Írans á morgun - Vísir

#utanríkisráðherra#sendimenn#morgun#trump#írans
70-year-old man revived after drowning incident at beach in Costa Adeje
📅 24.04.2026 19:11:00 👁️ 0

70-year-old man revived after drowning incident at beach in Costa Adeje

#drowning#incident#revived#after#beach
Segist vera réttmætur eigandi Mosa og vera hafður fyrir rangri sök - DV
📅 24.04.2026 18:56:56 👁️ 0

Segist vera réttmætur eigandi Mosa og vera hafður fyrir rangri sök - DV

#réttmætur#eigandi#segist#hafður#rangri
The unexpected benefits of upgrading your Golf Bag
📅 24.04.2026 18:55:00 👁️ 0

The unexpected benefits of upgrading your Golf Bag

#unexpected#upgrading#benefits#your#golf
Sjálfstæðisflokkur tekur fram úr Samfylkingu í borginni
📅 24.04.2026 18:49:07 👁️ 0

Sjálfstæðisflokkur tekur fram úr Samfylkingu í borginni

#sjálfstæðisflokkur#samfylkingu#borginni#tekur#fram
Sonur Reiner sendir frá sér tilfinningaþrungna yfirlýsingu
📅 24.04.2026 18:31:50 👁️ 0

Sonur Reiner sendir frá sér tilfinningaþrungna yfirlýsingu

#tilfinningaþrungna#yfirlýsingu#reiner#sendir#sonur
Bilið á milli turnanna breikkar - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 18:31:45 👁️ 0

Bilið á milli turnanna breikkar - Vísir

#turnanna#breikkar#bilið#milli#vísir
Hluthafaspjallið | Viðtal við Jón Þorstein, forstjóra Beru – og ruglið í danska Berlingske
📅 24.04.2026 18:31:06 👁️ 0

Hluthafaspjallið | Viðtal við Jón Þorstein, forstjóra Beru – og ruglið í danska Berlingske

#hluthafaspjallið#berlingske#forstjóra#þorstein#viðtal
Vestur­lönd tali opin­skátt um fyrirætlað stríð við Rúss­land - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 18:30:09 👁️ 0

Vestur­lönd tali opin­skátt um fyrirætlað stríð við Rúss­land - Vísir

#vesturlönd#fyrirætlað#opinskátt#rússland#stríð
Channel 5 newsreader withdraws claims against Dan Walker
📅 24.04.2026 18:17:05 👁️ 0

Channel 5 newsreader withdraws claims against Dan Walker

#newsreader#withdraws#channel#against#claims
Oddvitaumræður í Borgarbyggð
📅 24.04.2026 18:10:03 👁️ 0

Oddvitaumræður í Borgarbyggð

#oddvitaumræður#borgarbyggð
Vendingar í borginni og tón­leikar í heima­húsum - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 18:05:44 👁️ 0

Vendingar í borginni og tón­leikar í heima­húsum - Vísir

#heimahúsum#vendingar#tónleikar#borginni#vísir
Director Rob Reiner's son Jake Reiner bares soul on how he found out his parents were dead
📅 24.04.2026 18:02:54 👁️ 0

Director Rob Reiner's son Jake Reiner bares soul on how he found out his parents were dead

#director#parents#reiner#bares#found
AENA take action to ease passport control queues for British arrivals
📅 24.04.2026 17:51:00 👁️ 0

AENA take action to ease passport control queues for British arrivals

#passport#arrivals#control#british#action
Sakamálarannsókn á hendur seðlabankastjóra felld niður
📅 24.04.2026 17:48:23 👁️ 1

Sakamálarannsókn á hendur seðlabankastjóra felld niður

#sakamálarannsókn#seðlabankastjóra#hendur#felld#niður
Evrópusambandið rannsakar meint brot Mandelsons meðan hann var viðskiptastjóri
📅 24.04.2026 17:39:00 👁️ 0

Evrópusambandið rannsakar meint brot Mandelsons meðan hann var viðskiptastjóri

#evrópusambandið#viðskiptastjóri#mandelsons#rannsakar#meint
Tveir af hverjum þremur á fjárhagsaðstoð í Reykjavík eru útlendingar - DV
📅 24.04.2026 17:30:53 👁️ 0

Tveir af hverjum þremur á fjárhagsaðstoð í Reykjavík eru útlendingar - DV

#fjárhagsaðstoð#útlendingar#reykjavík#hverjum#þremur
Fimm bíla á­rekstur á Reykja­nes­braut - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 17:28:01 👁️ 0

Fimm bíla á­rekstur á Reykja­nes­braut - Vísir

#reykjanesbraut#árekstur#vísir#fimm#bíla
Eva Margrét tekur við taumunum hjá ESJA Legal ehf. - DV
📅 24.04.2026 17:01:55 👁️ 0

Eva Margrét tekur við taumunum hjá ESJA Legal ehf. - DV

#taumunum#margrét#tekur#legal#esja
Fimm bíla árekstur á Reykjanesbraut
📅 24.04.2026 17:01:40 👁️ 0

Fimm bíla árekstur á Reykjanesbraut

#reykjanesbraut#árekstur#fimm#bíla
Nokkurra bíla árekstur á Reykjanesbraut
📅 24.04.2026 17:01:40 👁️ 0

Nokkurra bíla árekstur á Reykjanesbraut

#reykjanesbraut#nokkurra#árekstur#bíla
Nútíma óligarkinn – Kristján Arason, Centra ráðgjöf og skatta undanskotin
📅 24.04.2026 16:57:35 👁️ 0

Nútíma óligarkinn – Kristján Arason, Centra ráðgjöf og skatta undanskotin

#undanskotin#óligarkinn#kristján#ráðgjöf#nútíma
Lista­verkið muni auka öryggi og vernda náttúruna á svæðinu - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 16:55:31 👁️ 0

Lista­verkið muni auka öryggi og vernda náttúruna á svæðinu - Vísir

#listaverkið#náttúruna#svæðinu#öryggi#vernda
Tveir helstu samningamenn Bandaríkjanna á leið til fundar við utanríkisráðherra Írans
📅 24.04.2026 16:47:29 👁️ 0

Tveir helstu samningamenn Bandaríkjanna á leið til fundar við utanríkisráðherra Írans

#utanríkisráðherra#bandaríkjanna#samningamenn#helstu#fundar
Orrustuþotur höfðu afskipti af rússneskum herþotum innan lofthelginnar
📅 24.04.2026 16:47:16 👁️ 0

Orrustuþotur höfðu afskipti af rússneskum herþotum innan lofthelginnar

#lofthelginnar#orrustuþotur#rússneskum#afskipti#herþotum
Dagur segir enga hættu felast í því að láta reyna á samninga við ESB - DV
📅 24.04.2026 16:30:53 👁️ 0

Dagur segir enga hættu felast í því að láta reyna á samninga við ESB - DV

#samninga#felast#dagur#segir#hættu
Hegseth segir Írana hafa sögulegt tækifæri til samkomulags við Bandaríkin
📅 24.04.2026 16:20:33 👁️ 0

Hegseth segir Írana hafa sögulegt tækifæri til samkomulags við Bandaríkin

#samkomulags#bandaríkin#sögulegt#tækifæri#hegseth
Israeli police investigate after officers 'cut Palestinian flag' from skullcap
📅 24.04.2026 16:20:10 👁️ 0

Israeli police investigate after officers 'cut Palestinian flag' from skullcap

#investigate#palestinian#officers#skullcap#israeli
Mandelson under formal investigation by EU's anti-fraud office
📅 24.04.2026 16:18:19 👁️ 0

Mandelson under formal investigation by EU's anti-fraud office

#investigation#mandelson#formal#office#under
Sinueldur kviknaði við bensín­stöð - Vísir
📅 24.04.2026 16:13:48 👁️ 0

Sinueldur kviknaði við bensín­stöð - Vísir

#bensínstöð#sinueldur#kviknaði#vísir
Horfðu til himins
📅 24.04.2026 16:10:00 👁️ 0

Horfðu til himins

#horfðu#himins
Segir leik Snorra í High School Musical fyrirboða
📅 24.04.2026 16:08:00 👁️ 0

Segir leik Snorra í High School Musical fyrirboða

#fyrirboða#musical#snorra#school#segir
Sinueldur við N1 í Fossvogi
📅 24.04.2026 15:56:06 👁️ 0

Sinueldur við N1 í Fossvogi

#sinueldur#fossvogi
Starfsfólk N1 slökkti sinueld skammt frá bensínstöðinni
📅 24.04.2026 15:56:06 👁️ 0

Starfsfólk N1 slökkti sinueld skammt frá bensínstöðinni

#bensínstöðinni#starfsfólk#slökkti#sinueld#skammt
Leikskólapláss losna óvænt í Vesturbænum
📅 24.04.2026 15:53:12 👁️ 0

Leikskólapláss losna óvænt í Vesturbænum

#leikskólapláss#vesturbænum#losna#óvænt
Tveir Íslendingar týndir á erlendri grundu í níu mánuði
📅 24.04.2026 15:33:25 👁️ 0

Tveir Íslendingar týndir á erlendri grundu í níu mánuði

#íslendingar#erlendri#týndir#grundu#mánuði