Former US officials criticise Pentagon silence on deadly Iran school attack

Former US officials criticise Pentagon silence on deadly Iran school attack

Former US officials criticise Pentagon silence on deadly Iran school attack

Five former US officials, including a former top military lawyer, have criticised the Pentagon for not acknowledging potential American involvement in a deadly strike on an Iranian school earlier this year.

Some of those officials said it was highly unusual not to release even basic details of the strike after such a length of time.

A missile hit a primary school in Minab during the opening salvos of the US-Israeli war on February 28, killing 168 people including around 110 children according to Iranian officials.

In the two months since then the Pentagon has said only that the incident is under investigation.

US media reported in early March that US military investigators believed American forces were likely responsible for hitting the school unintentionally but had not reached a final conclusion.

Asked a series of questions by the BBC about the strike and the accusations of a lack of transparency, a Pentagon official said "this incident is currently under investigation," adding that more details would be provided when they became available.

The BBC has reviewed three historical cases in which civilians were killed during US military operations and in each case significantly more information had been released by the Pentagon within less than a month.

The current US position "strikingly departs from the standard response," said Lt Col Rachel E VanLandingham, a retired Judge Advocate General in the US Air Force and former senior legal adviser at US Central Command during the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

"Administrations in the past at least demonstrated fidelity, a commitment to the law of war," said VanLandingham, who argued what was "missing" from the administration's statements was a commitment to accountability and "importantly to ensure this doesn't happen again".

President Trump said on 7 March that in his "opinion" Iran was to blame for the Minab strike, without providing evidence. Days later, when asked about video showing a US Tomahawk hitting the military base next to the school, he said: "I haven't seen it" and claimed without evidence that Iran had Tomahawk missiles.

On 11 March, when asked about reports that an initial military probe had found that the US hit the school, Trump said: "I don't know about it".

Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth was asked by the BBC on 4 March about the strike and said: "All I can say is that we're investigating that. We of course never target civilian targets".

The US Department of Defense has declined to answer multiple questions about the strike. It has repeatedly declined to answer whether the Iranian military base next to the school was one of its pre-planned targets on 28 February, despite speaking publicly about pre-planned targets or operations in dozens of other instances in the war.

Last month, the BBC independently confirmed video showing a US Tomahawk missile striking the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) base next to the school. US media reports quoted unnamed military officials saying a preliminary inquiry had determined a US missile struck the school. The reports said this was due to outdated target coordinates supplied by a US intelligence agency. The Pentagon has not commented on the reports.

Wes Bryant, a former senior adviser on precision warfare and civilian harm mitigation at the Pentagon's Civilian Protection Center of Excellence, told the BBC that the military's preliminary inquiry would routinely take place to establish two things: whether the civilian harm actually took place, and whether the US was operating in the area at the time and could have caused it.

"When you meet both of those criteria, that's the only time that an investigation is actually formally initiated," he said. "From a process standpoint… that just points even more to the fact that they know already that the US caused this or else they wouldn't doing this investigation and they just don't want to acknowledge it or speak to it."

"To not even be able to have any comment on it whatsoever is just unacceptable," said Bryant, who left the Pentagon last year when staffing at the civilian harm unit was significantly reduced under Hegseth.

Another former defence official said it was common for some civilian harm investigations to take a long time depending on the complexity of the situation. "But this is a case where… it's unusually opaque in that I can tell from the situation it's actually not that complicated," the former official, who asked not to be identified due to the sensitivity of the subject matter, told the BBC.

"Normally the Pentagon would take immediate [or] relatively fast responsibility and then probably require a longer period of time to provide all the details, so to me it's problematic," the former official added.

Congressional Democrats have written several times to Hegseth asking a series of questions about the Minab strike, starting with whether the US carried it out.

The BBC has seen two of the Pentagon's response letters, sent on behalf of Hegseth, which give no answers to any of the questions. A letter sent on 2 April to Democrats said an investigating officer from outside the CENTCOM chain of command had been appointed and the results of that investigation would be shared once completed.

The BBC approached 15 Republican members of Congress asking about the administration's handling of the strike, but all declined to comment. They included top Republicans on committees covering national security in the Senate and House of Representatives.

On March 10, Republican Senator John Kennedy of Louisiana condemned the strike, telling the New York Times: "I think we made a mistake. It was a terrible, terrible mistake."

Pentagon officials have given several closed-door briefings on military operations to members of Congress since the start of the war on Iran, and have been asked questions about the Minab strike.

Adam Smith, the top Democrat on the House Armed Services Committee, told the BBC the officials said they could not comment due to their ongoing investigation, a response he called "pathetic and completely inadequate". He said there had been no admission of US responsibility in the briefings.

The BBC has reviewed three historical cases involving civilian fatalities to form a comparison with the Trump administration's response to the Minab strike.

Each of the historical cases, under both Democratic and Republican administrations, involved senior US military officials making significantly more detailed public comments than has been the case so far in the Minab strike.

Annie Shiel, a former US official who worked on civilian harm reduction at the state department, said previous cases followed a pattern where the US had "come out and said 'it was not us', only for media and [non governmental organisation] reporting to show that in fact it was a US strike, and then the US has to walk that back."

The Pentagon's appointment in the Minab case of an investigating officer outside CENTCOM was "at least on paper a good start on independence", said Shiel who is now US Advocacy Director with the Center for Civilians in Conflict (CIVIC).

But she told the BBC she would "absolutely" expect further acknowledgement of any US role while the probe is ongoing.

Corroborating details about the incident has also been complicated by the fact Iranian authorities have not granted independent access to the site. The UN Fact Finding Mission on Iran said on 17 March it had sought access but not been permitted to visit the site.

Charles O Blaha, former director of the State Department's Office of Security and Human Rights, said a lack of transparency in Washington could stem from a "reluctance" within the administration to contradict the president after he blamed Iran for the strike, a claim he described as "really far-fetched and very clearly not true".

Blaha spent 32 years in the US foreign service and is now a senior adviser to Democracy for the Arab World Now (DAWN). He attributed the relative silence in the Minab case to what he saw as a rejection by the administration of "any negative news about the war they branded as unpatriotic".

Additional reporting by Catherine Alaimo

A timeline of satellite images from 2013, 2016 and 2022 that shows a wall was built separating the school from the IRGC base.
Aftermath of a drone strike near Kabul airport in Afghanistan in August 2021
#criticise #former #officials #pentagon #silence


Upprunaleg slóð:
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwy2482pn0lo

📰 Aðrar fréttir

Veðrinu nokkuð misskipt eftir landshlutum
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 0
Veðrinu nokkuð misskipt eftir landshlutum
Norðlæg átt ræður ríkjum næstu daga og veðrinu verður nokkuð misskipt eftir landshlutum.Bjartast og hlýjast verður sunnan- og vestanlands og á Vestfjö...
Sætir morð­hótunum og ó­hróðri í vin­sælum í Facebook-hópi - Vísir
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 0
Sætir morð­hótunum og ó­hróðri í vin­sælum í Facebook-hópi - Vísir
„Það er svo ótrúlega mikið af viðbjóði sem er tengt þessu en ég held áfram að halda hópnum uppi svo það sé vettvangur fyrir konur sem virkilega þurfa ...
Gabríel Douane og fimm aðrir sýknaðir - Vísir
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 0
Gabríel Douane og fimm aðrir sýknaðir - Vísir
Héraðdómur Reykjavíkur kvað upp dóm þess efnis á mánudag.  Sigurður Ólafsson, saksóknari hjá Héraðssaksóknara staðfestir niðurstöðu dómsins í svari ti...
María Gréta var 17 ára þegar sonur hennar lést: „Mjög skelfileg lífsreynsla sem ég hef unnið vel úr núna“
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 0
María Gréta var 17 ára þegar sonur hennar lést: „Mjög skelfileg lífsreynsla sem ég hef unnið vel úr núna“
María Gréta Einarsdóttir, framkvæmdastjóri NTC, var aðeins 17 ára gömul þegar frumburður hennar, Aron, dó vöggudauða aðeins þriggja og hálfs mánaðar g...
Fullum gámi af kampavíni stolið af Ölgerðinni
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 0
Fullum gámi af kampavíni stolið af Ölgerðinni
Heill gámur af kampavíni sem var á leið til landsins hvarf sporlaust í Rotterdam í Hollandi fyrr í sumar. Þar glataði Ölgerðin sumarsendingu sinni af ...
Allt að á­tján stigum og létt­skýjað vestan­lands - Vísir
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 0
Allt að á­tján stigum og létt­skýjað vestan­lands - Vísir
Þetta segir á vef Veðurstofu Íslands. Á morgun bætist í vind en þá er spáð norðvestan átt, átta til átján metrum á sekúndu og hvassast suðaustantil á ...
Fjögur börn látin eftir loft­á­rásir Rússa á borgir Úkraínu - Vísir
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 0
Fjögur börn látin eftir loft­á­rásir Rússa á borgir Úkraínu - Vísir
Einn lést í Kænugarði og eldar eru sagðir loga víða í borginni. Í Lviv er leitað að fólki í húsarústum eftir að eldflaugar lentu á tveimur fjölbýlishú...
Þorsteinn Pálsson skrifar: Kosið um öflugri verkfæri en ekki ný markmið
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Þorsteinn Pálsson skrifar: Kosið um öflugri verkfæri en ekki ný markmið
Mynd Mörgum þykir nóg um æsinginn í umræðunni um þjóðaratkvæðagr
„Þegar við sáum kastalann var ekki aftur snúið“ - Vísir
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
„Þegar við sáum kastalann var ekki aftur snúið“ - Vísir
Sædís starfar á fjármálasviði hjá LSR lífeyrissjóði og Henrik er kennari og ráðgjafi hjá Klettabæ en þau eru bæði fædd árið 1996. Þau byrjuðu saman fy...
Gladiator kveikti neistann við brennuna og úr varð ó­dauð­legt þjóðhátíðarlag - Vísir
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 0
Gladiator kveikti neistann við brennuna og úr varð ó­dauð­legt þjóðhátíðarlag - Vísir
Þegar eldurinn verður kveiktur í Herjólfsdal um næstu helgi og þúsundir gesta fylla brekkuna er eitt lag nánast óaðskiljanlegt frá augnablikinu, „Þar ...
Útivist og iðnaður: Ferðasvæði höfuðborgarbúa í hættu
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Útivist og iðnaður: Ferðasvæði höfuðborgarbúa í hættu
Útivist og iðnaður: Ferðasvæði höfuðborgarbúa í hættu Þrátt fyr­ir mik­il­vægi úti­vist­ar fyr­ir lík­ama og sál hef­ur ver­ið geng­ið á ýmsa staði se...
Franska lögreglan segist hafa fyrirmæli um að stöðva ekki báta innflytjenda sem halda til Bretlands – „Okkur er sagt að leyfa þeim að fara“
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Franska lögreglan segist hafa fyrirmæli um að stöðva ekki báta innflytjenda sem halda til Bretlands – „Okkur er sagt að leyfa þeim að fara“
Franskir lögreglumenn segjast hafa fyrirmæli um að grípa ekki inn í þegar innflytjendur sjósetja smábáta og halda af stað yfir Ermarsundið til Bretlan...
Three teenagers arrested over 12 shop burglaries in South Tenerife
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Three teenagers arrested over 12 shop burglaries in South Tenerife
The Guardia Civil have arrested three teenage boys in connection with a series of 12 break-ins at commercial premises in Granadilla de Abona, in the s...
Heilum gámi af kampa­víni stolið af Öl­gerðinni - Vísir
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Heilum gámi af kampa­víni stolið af Öl­gerðinni - Vísir
Þetta segir Egill Sigurðsson, vörumerkjastjóri hjá Ölgerðinni, en fyrirtækið lenti í því fyrr í sumar að gámur fullur af Moët & Chandon og Dom Périgno...
Holidaymaker nearly drowns after being trapped by hotel pool filter in Gran Canaria
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Holidaymaker nearly drowns after being trapped by hotel pool filter in Gran Canaria
A 45-year-old man is recovering after a terrifying accident at a hotel in southern Gran Canaria, where he was nearly drowned after becoming trapped by...
Árásir víða í Úkraínu í nótt
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Árásir víða í Úkraínu í nótt
Að minnsta kosti átta voru drepnir og tugir særðust í árásum víða um Úkraínu í nótt. Kyiv Independent segir að þrjátíu séu særðir eftir árásirnar.Eldf...
Spain pledges €1 billion to bring world's largest northern hemisphere telescope to the Canary Islands
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Spain pledges €1 billion to bring world's largest northern hemisphere telescope to the Canary Islands
The Spanish Government has unveiled a €1 billion financial package aimed at securing La Palma as the future home of the Thirty Metre Telescope (TMT), ...
Red Flag remains at beach in Lanzarote after sewage contamination is confirmed
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Red Flag remains at beach in Lanzarote after sewage contamination is confirmed
Swimming and bathing remains prohibited at El Reducto Beach in Arrecife, Lanzarote, after the Canary Islands Health Department confirmed high levels o...
Serial killer James Desborough preyed on vulnerable homeless men
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Serial killer James Desborough preyed on vulnerable homeless men
Killer James Desborough cut up and burned his victims before dumping them in woodland near his home.
Bretar verja um 1.400 milljörðum króna í nýja kjarnorkukafbáta
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Bretar verja um 1.400 milljörðum króna í nýja kjarnorkukafbáta
Breska ríkisstjórnin hyggst verja 8,4 milljörðum punda, jafnvirði tæplega 1.400 milljarða íslenskra króna, í næsta áfanga Dreadnought-áætlunarinnar um...
Israel building new land barriers in Gaza and displacing families
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Israel building new land barriers in Gaza and displacing families
Experts have told the BBC that the earthworks suggest Israel is planning for a long-term internal border.
Enn ekki búið að ráða niðurlögum allra skógareldanna
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Enn ekki búið að ráða niðurlögum allra skógareldanna
Um 8.500 manns sem þurftu að yfirgefa heimili sín á Spáni vegna skógareldanna hafa nú fengið að fara aftur heim til sín. Sumir komu að húsum sínum ósk...
Children among eight dead in Russian strikes, Ukraine officials say
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Children among eight dead in Russian strikes, Ukraine officials say
Two girls, aged 5 and 12, were among the six killed in a village near the central Ukrainian city of Kryvyi Rih, while Kyiv and Poltava also saw fatali...
Singapore fines French teen for iJooz vending machine straw-licking stunt
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Singapore fines French teen for iJooz vending machine straw-licking stunt
The 19-year-old was "truly sorry" for causing trouble, his lawyers said.
Tala látinna komin í 17 eftir jarðskjálftann
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Tala látinna komin í 17 eftir jarðskjálftann
Yfirvöld í Kumamoto-héraði á Kyushu-eyju í suðvesturhluta Japan segja að 17 séu látnir eftir jarðskjálftann sem varð í Kumamoto á þriðjudag. Á fjórða ...
Tala látinna komin í 28 eftir jarðskjálftann
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Tala látinna komin í 28 eftir jarðskjálftann
Yfirvöld í Kumamoto-héraði á Kyushu-eyju í suðvesturhluta Japan segja að 28 séu látnir eftir jarðskjálftann sem varð í Kumamoto á þriðjudag. Á fjórða ...
Tala látinna komin í 30 eftir jarðskjálftann
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Tala látinna komin í 30 eftir jarðskjálftann
Yfirvöld í Kumamoto-héraði á Kyushu-eyju í suðvesturhluta Japan segja að 30 séu látnir eftir jarðskjálftann sem varð í Kumamoto á þriðjudag. Á fjórða ...
Minnst 30 látnir eftir skjálftann í Kumamoto
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 0
Minnst 30 látnir eftir skjálftann í Kumamoto
Yfirvöld í Kumamoto-héraði á Kyushu-eyju í suðvesturhluta Japan segja að 30 séu látnir eftir jarðskjálftann sem varð í Kumamoto á þriðjudag. Á fjórða ...
UK weather: Cooler conditions on way for parts of UK as cold front moves in
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
UK weather: Cooler conditions on way for parts of UK as cold front moves in
After another day of record-breaking temperatures for some parts of England, a cold front is moving in.
Níu drepnir og fjórtán særðust í drónaárás
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Níu drepnir og fjórtán særðust í drónaárás
Níu voru drepnir og fjórtán særðust í drónaárás RSF-uppreisnarhersins á þorp í Norður-Kordofan í Súdan í gærmorgun. RSF-uppreisnarherinn er að reyna a...
US launches 'powerful' strikes on Iran after attempted attack on American troops
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
US launches 'powerful' strikes on Iran after attempted attack on American troops
The US military called the strikes "a powerful response" to Tuesday's firing by Iran on US bases in Jordan.
US launches 'heavy' strikes on Iran after attempted attack on American troops
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
US launches 'heavy' strikes on Iran after attempted attack on American troops
The US military said the strikes were in response to Iran firing missiles at US forces in the Middle East on Tuesday.
Nuclear submarine investment will protect Britain and boost jobs, PM says
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 1
Nuclear submarine investment will protect Britain and boost jobs, PM says
Speaking ahead of a visit to Barrow-in-Furness, the PM seeks to stress the economic benefits of defence spending.
Mosfellsdalur minnti á víg­völl - Vísir
📅 30.07.2026 👁️ 2
Mosfellsdalur minnti á víg­völl - Vísir
„Staðan er talsvert betri en í morgun, þetta var auðvitað ófremdarástand þegar við mættum,“ sagði Hilmar Gunnarsson bæjarstjóri Mosfellsbæjar. Í tilky...
What Britain's air-con row tells us about fighting climate change
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 2
What Britain's air-con row tells us about fighting climate change
Should we embrace air conditioning despite its costs and consequences, and how much should we spend on adapting homes versus cutting carbon?
How the UK's extreme heat is shifting the conversation about air-con
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 1
How the UK's extreme heat is shifting the conversation about air-con
Should we embrace air conditioning despite its costs and consequences, and how much should we spend on adapting homes versus cutting carbon?
MoD data breach a 'foreseeable' failure that left Afghans in danger, inquiry finds
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 2
MoD data breach a 'foreseeable' failure that left Afghans in danger, inquiry finds
The Commons' Defence Committee says in a report that the MoD used secrecy as a "shield" against proper expertise.
Interest rates expected to be held again by Bank of England
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 2
Interest rates expected to be held again by Bank of England
It would be the fifth hold in a row, with the Bank rate standing at 3.75% - the lowest since February 2023.
Líkamsleifar fimm ungbarna fundust á heimili í Frakklandi
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 2
Líkamsleifar fimm ungbarna fundust á heimili í Frakklandi
Líkamsleifar sem taldar eru vera af fimm ungbörnum fundust í íbúð pars í bænum Orange í Provence-héraði í suðausturhluta Frakklands. Samkvæmt frétt Re...
Kíkti í kaffi til kanslarans - Vísir
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 2
Kíkti í kaffi til kanslarans - Vísir
„Við Merz ræddum m.a. stöðu mála á alþjóðasviðinu, bárum saman bækur um innanlandspólitík og fórum yfir Evrópumálin,“ segir Kristrún í færslunni. „Han...
Salman Rushdie attacker convicted of terror offenses
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 2
Salman Rushdie attacker convicted of terror offenses
Hadi Matar, 28, was convicted of attempting to help Hezbollah by attacking the British-Indian author.
Greinir á um leiðir til að draga úr nikótínneyslu ung­menna - Vísir
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 2
Greinir á um leiðir til að draga úr nikótínneyslu ung­menna - Vísir
Heilbrigðisráðuneytið hefur birt drög að frumvarpi um nikótín- og tóbaksvarnir í Samráðsgátt stjórnvalda. Með þeim yrðu núgildandi lög um tóbaksvarnir...
Rósa krefst svara frá lögreglunni - „Hver var lúkningin?“
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 2
Rósa krefst svara frá lögreglunni - „Hver var lúkningin?“
Rósa Guðbjartsdóttir alþingismaður Sjálfstæðisflokksins segir að í ljósi innbrotsins í minkabúið í Mosfellsdal í nótt sé komin tími til að einhver svö...
„Knúsfundur“ Trumps með Pútín hafi skilað litlu
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 1
„Knúsfundur“ Trumps með Pútín hafi skilað litlu
Merkja má aukinn stuðning Bandaríkjastjórnar gagnvart Úkraínu eftir leiðtogafund forseta ríkjanna tveggja í Washington í gær. Úkraínumenn fá að framle...
Gæslu­varð­hald sam­þykkt yfir Ming Ting - Vísir
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 2
Gæslu­varð­hald sam­þykkt yfir Ming Ting - Vísir
Mancel hafði fram til þessa sætt farbanni en sætir nú gæsluvarðhaldi að kröfu héraðssaksóknara. „Ég er að kæra þá niðurstöðu til Landsréttar,“ staðfes...
Þórir var heimilislaus og svaf í bílakjallara – Nú er hann bílstjóri borgarstjóra: „Mig langaði ekki til að lifa“
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 2
Þórir var heimilislaus og svaf í bílakjallara – Nú er hann bílstjóri borgarstjóra: „Mig langaði ekki til að lifa“
„Ég er alkahólisti og gekk í gengum dimma dali í mínu lífi,“ segir Þórir Kjartansson bílstjóri og öryggisvörður borgarstjóra. Þórir er gestur Viktoríu...
„Það er búið að slökkva og húsið er ó­nýtt“ - Vísir
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 2
„Það er búið að slökkva og húsið er ó­nýtt“ - Vísir
„Þetta gekk ágætlega miðað við aðstæður,“ segir Einar. Slökkvistarfi lauk um hálfáttaleytið í kvöld. Íbúar hússins voru komnir út þegar slökkvilið kom...
„Þetta er afleiðing af dýravernduninni þeirra“
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 2
„Þetta er afleiðing af dýravernduninni þeirra“
Mörg hundruð minkar, að minnsta kosti, sluppu úr loðdýrabúinu Dalsbúi í Mosfellsdal eftir innbrot og skemmdarverk.Um tólf þúsund dýr voru í búinu. Þeg...
Zendaya on working with Tom Holland in Spider-Man: Brand New Day - ‘When it’s your best friend it’s easy’
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 2
Zendaya on working with Tom Holland in Spider-Man: Brand New Day - ‘When it’s your best friend it’s easy’
The couple walked the white carpet at the London premiere of their latest film, Spiderman: Brand New Day.
Zendaya on working with Tom Holland in Spider-Man: ‘When you’re best friends it’s easy’
📅 29.07.2026 👁️ 1
Zendaya on working with Tom Holland in Spider-Man: ‘When you’re best friends it’s easy’
The couple walked the white carpet at the London premiere of their latest film, Spiderman: Brand New Day.