Paul Quinn's 24-year sentence an 'insult', says wrongly convicted Andrew Malkinson

Paul Quinn's 24-year sentence an 'insult', says wrongly convicted Andrew Malkinson

Paul Quinn's 24-year sentence an 'insult', says wrongly convicted Andrew Malkinson

Andrew Malkinson has said the sentence given to the rapist responsible for the attack for which he was wrongly imprisoned for 17 years is an "insult".

Paul Quinn, 52, was given a 24-year sentence for attacking a woman in the Little Hulton area of Salford in 2003, but could be eligible for parole in 14 years.

Malkinson - wrongly convicted in one of the worst miscarriages of justice in British history - said Quinn was a "violent, depraved individual" but had received "a softer sentence" than his life term.

Jurors at Manchester Crown Court heard Quinn's DNA was found on the woman's vest and he had searched online to see how long police kept samples.

The victim, referred to as a "hero" by the judge, said the impact of the rape attack would "remain with me for life".

Quinn, from Exeter in Devon and formerly of Little Hulton, was also found guilty in April of strangulation and causing grievous bodily harm.

The father-of-six did not react as he was given a 24-year sentence, comprising of 21 years in prison with an extended licence period of three years.

After the sentencing hearing, Malkinson said: "I am insulted that this violent, depraved individual - who was content to let me suffer two decades of vilification and more than 17 years wrongly imprisoned for his crime - has received a softer sentence than was imposed on me, an innocent man.

"I got sentenced to life imprisonment and served more than 17 years inside.

"Throughout that time I didn't know if I would ever be released."

He added that he hoped Quinn would not get parole and would ultimately serve a longer sentence than he had.

"Anything less is not justice," he said.

The court heard Quinn, who was 29 at the time, attacked the young mother, aged in her 30s, as she walked home in the early hours of the morning on 19 July 2003.

She was brutally beaten, bitten and her cheekbone was fractured before being strangled unconscious and raped.

Malkinson, who had been working as a security guard at a local shopping centre at the time of the attack, was wrongly picked out at an identity parade.

He protested his innocence but was jailed in 2004.

Malkinson, now aged 60, failed in several appeals against his conviction in 2012 and 2020.

He was only released in 2020 after 17 years in jail, with his conviction finally quashed by the Court of Appeal in 2023.

The victim wept in court as her lawyer read out her impact statement: "For [Quinn] it was one night of his life; for me it was one night that changed my life.

"After 20 years I now have justice but that does not change the fact that two lives have been impacted in such a way.

"I am aware that someone has had 17 years robbed as a result of this case and that stays with me.

"As for me, the impact of what happened that day has stayed with me and will remain with me for life."

She added that every day she looked at her face and saw the disfigurement and scarring that had been inflicted upon her in the attack.

"It is a permanent reminder of that night and what I experienced," she said. "I have to live with that."

Addressing Quinn directly, Mr Justice Robert Bright said: "She, not you Paul Quinn, is the person from this case who I will remember for the rest of my days.

"She is truly a hero."

Before he passed sentence, the judge said it was obvious how "excruciating" it must have been for the victim to come back to court for a second time.

"She is a remarkable person," he added.

"You sat back and enjoyed your liberty at the expense of an innocent man.

"It's true you never did anything to implicate Mr Malkinson, however, but for you he would never have even been questioned."

The court heard Quinn was a convicted sex offender at the time of the attack.

He was cautioned in 1986 for two counts of indecent assault against a female, when he was 12 years old.

In November 1992, he was convicted of two counts of underage sex, an offence which today would be classified as rape.

Mr Justice Bright said Quinn was aged 15 or 16 and the girl was 13 at the time of the offences.

It was this offence that led to his DNA being taken by police a decade later, which ultimately linked him to the 2003 rape.

The six-week trial heard Quinn stalked his victim as she walked home, dragging her from the street and down a motorway embankment.

He was finally brought to justice after saliva found on her top was recovered years later.

Greater Manchester Police (GMP) said it was appealing for any further potential victims of Quinn to come forward.

Senior Investigating Officer Det Ch Supt Rebecca McKendrick said: "We know this outcome has come two decades too late for those impacted by this case.

"However, we will not allow time to be a barrier to justice for anyone who has further information about Paul Quinn and any further potential sexual offending."

McKendrick added that she knew key questions must be answered by the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) and a judge-led inquiry about Malkinson's wrongful conviction.

"GMP stands ready to support these vital reviews," she said.

"Today brings to a close the criminal chapter to this case.

"The right man - this horrific attacker, Paul Quinn - is finally behind bars."

Fallout from the case continues, with a public inquiry now under way after a 2024 review found failings that could have exonerated Malkinson a decade before he was eventually released from prison.

Five former GMP officers, and one currently serving with the force, are under investigation by the IOPC with both the chair and chief executive of the Criminal Cases Review Commission having resigned.

Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.

Greater Manchester Police A mugshot of Paul Quinn, who is wearing a blue top, has light stubble, and is staring vacantly forward.
PA Media Andrew Malkinson wearing a black shirt standing outside next to a crowd.
GMP Paul Quinn, sitting in a police interview room, has short dark hair and is wearing a grey sweatshirt over a blue top.
GMP A young Paul Quinn wearing a red t-shirt with sunglasses on his head smiles.
#insult #paul #quinn #sentence #year


Upprunaleg slóð:
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c99l93md0gko?at_medium=RSS&at_campaign=rss

📰 Aðrar fréttir

Hættu að vinna 35 og 40 ára – þetta gerðu þau öðruvísi en flestir
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Hættu að vinna 35 og 40 ára – þetta gerðu þau öðruvísi en flestir
Sífellt fleiri kjósa að lifa afar sparlega í þeirri von að geta hætt að vinna mörgum árum fyrr en almennt tíðkast. Bresk hjón sem hættu bæði að vinna ...
Fjölgun ungs fólks í leiguhúsnæði merki um stækkandi markað
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Fjölgun ungs fólks í leiguhúsnæði merki um stækkandi markað
Fjölgun ungs fólks á leigumarkaði gæti verið merki um stækkandi leigumarkað, segir yfirhagfræðingur Húsnæðis- og mannvirkjastofnunar. Hlutfall fólks á...
Undir­rita sam­komu­lag sem opnar á úranauðgun Sáda - Vísir
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Undir­rita sam­komu­lag sem opnar á úranauðgun Sáda - Vísir
New York Times greinir frá. Samkvæmt miðlinum verður samkomulagið undirritað í dag og þingið upplýst í framhaldinu. Búast má við andstöðu meðal þingma...
Nottingham attacks NHS trust faces manslaughter probe
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Nottingham attacks NHS trust faces manslaughter probe
The hospital trust treated Valdo Calocane before he killed three people in the city in 2023.
Spjallið með Frosta Logasyni | „Við þurfum ekki að láta bjarga okkur“ | Hermann um ESB og efnahagsmálin
„Svo setti hann á sig sítrusilminn og þá máttu jólin koma“ - Vísir
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
„Svo setti hann á sig sítrusilminn og þá máttu jólin koma“ - Vísir
„Ég myndi segja að kannski svona af því að ég er með ADHD þá er ég alveg ótrúlega næm á alla skynjun: hitastig, lykt og lýsingu,“ útskýrir Lilja Birgi...
Vilja fangelsa veitingamann með tvær Michelin-stjörnur fyrir að bera fram maura
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Vilja fangelsa veitingamann með tvær Michelin-stjörnur fyrir að bera fram maura
Saksóknarar í Suður-Kóreu fara fram á eins árs fangelsi yfir eiganda veitingahúss með tvær Michelin-stjörnur fyrir að nota maura í eftirrétt.Ástæðan e...
Fight on Tenerife flight forces emergency return to South Airport
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Fight on Tenerife flight forces emergency return to South Airport
An EasyJet flight from Tenerife South Airport to Liverpool was forced to turn back just 30 minutes after take-off yesterday (Tuesday) after a fight in...
Meiri vindur og úrkoma en vindar breytast brátt
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Meiri vindur og úrkoma en vindar breytast brátt
Útlit er fyrir meiri vind og meiri úrkomu í dag en var í gær. Gengur í sunnan og suðvestan 8 til 15 m/s með rigningu og súld.Úrkomusvæðið berst þó ekk...
Utan­ríkis­ráð­herrann lýsir á­rásunum sem urðu Khamenei að bana - Vísir
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Utan­ríkis­ráð­herrann lýsir á­rásunum sem urðu Khamenei að bana - Vísir
Utanríkisráðherrann lýsti atburðarásinni í viðtali við íranska blaðamanninn Javad Mogouyi, sem var tekið áður en átök brutust út að nýju milli Bandarí...
Segir Þorgerði Katrínu hafa sagt eina sögu á Íslandi og aðra í útlöndum
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Segir Þorgerði Katrínu hafa sagt eina sögu á Íslandi og aðra í útlöndum
Sigmundur Davíð Gunnlaugsson, formaður Miðflokksins, segir tímabært að Þorgerður Katrín Gunnarsdóttir utanríkisráðherra verði kölluð fyrir utanríkismá...
PC Andrew Harper killers may be eligible for early release
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
PC Andrew Harper killers may be eligible for early release
PC Harper, 28, sustained fatal injuries while responding to a quad bike theft in Berkshire in 2019.
Tamaragua Residences: Living on the Atlantic Coast in one of Tenerife's most privileged locations
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Tamaragua Residences: Living on the Atlantic Coast in one of Tenerife's most privileged locations
Puerto Santiago, in the municipality of Santiago del Teide, is one of the most desirable residential locations on Tenerife's west coast. Sheltered fro...
Tragedy as 12-year-old girl dies from drowning off beach in Gran Canaria
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Tragedy as 12-year-old girl dies from drowning off beach in Gran Canaria
A 12-year-old girl has tragically died from drowning after getting into difficulty in the sea at La Laja Beach in Las Palmas de Gran Canaria yesterday...
Streeting apologises after early prisoner release comments heard on mic
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Streeting apologises after early prisoner release comments heard on mic
The defence secretary and Mahmood were also heard making jokes about the new justice secretary.
Hafa náð tökum á víðfeðmum skógareldum í Suður-Frakklandi
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 1
Hafa náð tökum á víðfeðmum skógareldum í Suður-Frakklandi
Slökkviliðsmenn hafa náð tökum á víðfeðmum skógareldum sem hafa logað í Suður-Frakklandi frá því fyrr í vikunni. Þeir eiga þó enn eftir að ráða niðurl...
Sarwar ministerial role sees promotion of another Starmer critic
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Sarwar ministerial role sees promotion of another Starmer critic
Months after calling on Keir Starmer to quit, the Scottish Labour leader is set to become a minister in Burnham's government, the BBC's political edit...
Military kit prompts breast-fit concerns among women troops
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 0
Military kit prompts breast-fit concerns among women troops
Servicewomen still face shortages of properly fitting kit, five years after a landmark report.
Vill að Netanjahú verði handtekinn en segir borgaryfirvöld skorta heimild til þess
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 1
Vill að Netanjahú verði handtekinn en segir borgaryfirvöld skorta heimild til þess
Zohran Mamdani, borgarstjóri í New York, segir að borgaryfirvöld hafi ekki heimild til þess að framfylgja handtökuskipun Alþjóðlega sakamáladómstólsin...
Rebel Wilson cleared in defamation case brought by actress in her own film
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 1
Rebel Wilson cleared in defamation case brought by actress in her own film
Wilson was accused of defaming young Australian actress Charlotte MacInnes, but cleared by a Sydney court.
Leggja til að réttarhöld yfir Maduro hefjist eftir tæpt ár
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 1
Leggja til að réttarhöld yfir Maduro hefjist eftir tæpt ár
Saksóknarar dómsmálaráðuneytis Bandaríkjanna og lögmenn Nicolás Maduros, fyrrverandi forsætisráðherra Venesúela, hafa lagt til að réttarhöld yfir Madu...
US renews strikes on Iran as Trump threatens to attack Pickaxe Mountain
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 1
US renews strikes on Iran as Trump threatens to attack Pickaxe Mountain
The US president's threat to target a key Iranian nuclear site came ahead of the 11th consecutive night of attacks.
Loftvarnarkerfi í Tehran virkjuð eftir árásir Bandaríkjanna
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 1
Loftvarnarkerfi í Tehran virkjuð eftir árásir Bandaríkjanna
Stjórnstöð Bandaríkjahers greindi frá því í nótt að herinn hefði hafið árásir á Íran, elleftu nóttina í röð. Árásunum lauk um klukkan eitt eftir miðnæ...
Boðar 100% innflutningstoll á samheitalyf
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 1
Boðar 100% innflutningstoll á samheitalyf
Donald Trump forseti Bandaríkjanna hyggst leggja 100% toll á innflutning samheitalyfja til Bandaríkjanna. Hann greindi frá þessu í færslu á Truth Soci...
Burnham pulls back on suggestion to increase tax-free personal allowance
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 1
Burnham pulls back on suggestion to increase tax-free personal allowance
Burnham has previously said that the freeze in the tax allowance was a big issue in the Makerfield by-election
UK humanitarian worker monitored for Ebola in London hospital
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 1
UK humanitarian worker monitored for Ebola in London hospital
The health worker was evacuated to the UK from the DR Congo after being potentially exposed to the virus.
Stríðsrekstur Bandaríkjanna í Íran hefur kostað 37,5 milljarða dala
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 1
Stríðsrekstur Bandaríkjanna í Íran hefur kostað 37,5 milljarða dala
Stríðsreksturinn í Íran hefur kostað Bandaríkin 37,5 milljarða Bandaríkjadala eða sem jafngildir rúmlega 4.700 milljörðum króna. Það er litlu minna en...
Aukið að­gengi að á­fengi auki neyslu - Vísir
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 1
Aukið að­gengi að á­fengi auki neyslu - Vísir
Kári Stefánsson segir málið um netsölu áfengis vera tvískipt. Annars vegar hvort eigi að leyfa netsölu áfengis, sem hann telji óskynsamlegt vegna þess...
More women in their 20s are getting type 2 diabetes
📅 22.07.2026 👁️ 1
More women in their 20s are getting type 2 diabetes
England is seeing "a worrying increase" in women in their 20s developing type 2 diabetes, say experts. Here's what to look out for.
'I can't afford to turn the oven on': 7.4m households struggling to buy essentials
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
'I can't afford to turn the oven on': 7.4m households struggling to buy essentials
As Andy Burnham promises “breathing space” for households, millions are unable to buy items such as clothing, heating and food.
Great Apes kiss and cuddle to keep the peace, says study
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Great Apes kiss and cuddle to keep the peace, says study
Hugging before stressful events may be an ancient way of building trust, say scientists studying apes.
Judge rules Trump must hand over financial records sought by BBC in defamation case
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Judge rules Trump must hand over financial records sought by BBC in defamation case
The judge grants a motion to compel the release of files held by the Donald J Trump Revocable Trust.
Frakkland bannar samfélagsmiðla fyrir börn undir 15 ára
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Frakkland bannar samfélagsmiðla fyrir börn undir 15 ára
Franska þingið hefur samþykkt frumvarp sem bannar aðgang barna undir 15 ára aldri að samfélagsmiðlum. Verður Frakkland þar með fyrsta landið innan Evr...
Yfirhershöfðingja Úkraínuhers vikið úr starfi - Vísir
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Yfirhershöfðingja Úkraínuhers vikið úr starfi - Vísir
Fyrir fáeinum dögum var varnarmálaráðherra Úkraínu, Mykhailo Fedóróv, látinn taka pokann sinn en hann þótti tiltölulega vinsæll meðal almennings í Úkr...
Yfirhershöfðingja Úkraínuhers vikið úr em­bætti - Vísir
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 1
Yfirhershöfðingja Úkraínuhers vikið úr em­bætti - Vísir
Fyrir fáeinum dögum var varnarmálaráðherra Úkraínu, Mykhailo Fedóróv, látinn taka pokann sinn en hann þótti tiltölulega vinsæll meðal almennings í Úkr...
Forseti segir þjóðina verða að vakna og líta upp frá samfélagsmiðlum
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Forseti segir þjóðina verða að vakna og líta upp frá samfélagsmiðlum
Halla Tómasdóttir, forseti Íslands, undirbýr samtal þjóðar leitt af ungu fólki í október þegar 40 ár verða frá leiðtogafundinum í Höfða. Hún segir að ...
Stórsér á kind eftir árás Husky-hunds
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Stórsér á kind eftir árás Husky-hunds
Í færslu á Facebook síðunni segir Sigríður meðal annars: „Á þessu svæði er nú mikið af sauðfé á sumarbeit og þekkjandi til tegundarinnar vissi ég að þ...
Regn­boginn verði málaður aftur en með breyttu sniði - Vísir
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Regn­boginn verði málaður aftur en með breyttu sniði - Vísir
Öll málning var þrifin af tröppunum skömmu eftir að málað var yfir regnbogafánann í íslensku fánalitunum. Prófílmynd Grafarvogskirkju var uppfærð í sí...
Iran war has cost US $37.5bn so far, Hegseth says
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Iran war has cost US $37.5bn so far, Hegseth says
Some senators pushed back on Hegseth's funding request as he testified at a pivotal time in the war.
Iran war has cost US $37.5bn so far, Hegseth says, as Pentagon seeks billions more
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 1
Iran war has cost US $37.5bn so far, Hegseth says, as Pentagon seeks billions more
Some senators pushed back on Hegseth's funding request as he testified at a pivotal time in the war.
Tokyo urges men to wear shorts to work, but women say it's 'leg hair harassment'
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Tokyo urges men to wear shorts to work, but women say it's 'leg hair harassment'
The Tokyo Metropolitan Government wants workers to ditch the suit and tie for t-shirts, trainers - and shorts.
Rússar átt í leynilegum viðræðum við Þjóðverja
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Rússar átt í leynilegum viðræðum við Þjóðverja
Fyrrverandi embættismenn Þýskalands funduðu með rússneskum embættismönnum á laum í Baku, höfuðborg Aserbaísjan, í mánuðinum um leiðir til að binda end...
Segir „rúmdauða“ slæmt teikn í samböndum
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Segir „rúmdauða“ slæmt teikn í samböndum
Stuttu eftir að hafa talað um nýjan maka sinn, Caspar Jopling, í fyrsta skipti, er leikkonan Olivia Wilde farin að opna sig enn frekar um skoðanir sín...
Óhugnanlegar myndir: Husky-hundur beit sauðfé við Mjóanes
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Óhugnanlegar myndir: Husky-hundur beit sauðfé við Mjóanes
Ath. Viðkæmir eru varaðir við myndefni hér neðar í fréttinniSigríður Jónsdóttir, íbúi á Laugarvatni, greinir frá því á Facebook, að í morgun (miðvikud...
„Verið að herja á fólk sem er búið að missa maka“ - Vísir
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
„Verið að herja á fólk sem er búið að missa maka“ - Vísir
Um ástarsvik er að ræða þegar óprúttinn aðili myndar ástar- eða vinatengsl við einhvern á netinu með það fyrir stafni að hafa af viðkomandi fé eða per...
Yfirmaður úkraínska hersins rekinn
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Yfirmaður úkraínska hersins rekinn
Volodymyr Zelensky, forseti Úkraínu, hefur rekið yfirmann úkraínska hersins, Oleksandr Syrsky.Brottvikning hans kemur einungis nokkrum dögum eftir að ...
„Mikil­vægast að þetta verði ekki eins og ein­hver hótelsundlaug á Tenerife“ - Vísir
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
„Mikil­vægast að þetta verði ekki eins og ein­hver hótelsundlaug á Tenerife“ - Vísir
Tæplega sex áratugir eru frá því að Laugardalslaug var vígð í lok júlí 1968 og sömuleiðis áhorfendastúkan við laugina. Þar gátu tvö þúsund manns fylgs...
„Þegar Metallica eða Rammstein hringir hendum við okkur í gírinn“
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
„Þegar Metallica eða Rammstein hringir hendum við okkur í gírinn“
Byrjað var að reisa Heimskautsgerðið á Melrakkaási norðvestan við Raufarhöfn árið 2004. Gerðið er listaverk sem sækir innblástur í norræna goðafræði o...
Bandero stefnir í átt að Ís­landi á ný - Vísir
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Bandero stefnir í átt að Ís­landi á ný - Vísir
Magnús Pálmar Jónsson, staðgengill upplýsingafulltrúa Landhelgisgæslunnar, staðfesti í samtali við blaðamann Vísis að Bandero stefni nú í átt að Íslan...
Novo Nordisk fer í mál við Eli Lilly
📅 21.07.2026 👁️ 2
Novo Nordisk fer í mál við Eli Lilly
Danska lyfjafyrirtækið Novo Nordisk höfðar mál gegn lyfjafyrirtækinu Eli Lilly. Novo Nordisk heldur því fram að auglýsingar Eli Lilly fyrir þyngdarstj...